Judicial independence is essential to the
very foundation of our democratic society. However, it might not be a good
thing. Justice are supposed to act fairly and impartially no matter the
concerns of politics, demands of special interest groups or the popular
opinions of the majority. They make decisions after careful legal scrutiny
firmly grounded on the rule of law applied to the evidence of a case. Judicial independence
is the idea that the judges are not penalized for doing their responsibilities.
However, because they are independent, judges can ignore law and pursue private
agendas. nevertheless, judicial independence is important so that the judges do
not have to bow to the whims of the people and can instead only look at the
law. In 2009 the Supreme Court of Iowa unanimously held that same-sex couple
have a right to marry under the state constitution. A year later, Iowans voted
out three justices who joined the opinion.
Judicial
independence is centered around the idea of being independent from politics.
When politics influence the court, it negatively effects judicial independence
because there is no way to control the courts. However, if courts are not
independent than they can suffer decisions from politics and the people.
Judicial independence also helps present an image that the courts are not influenced
by politics even if they are.
What is your opinion on the newly appointed justice related to judicial independence?
ReplyDelete