Monday, February 25, 2019

Week 4 Post 3 Specialized Federal Agencies and the Process of the Supreme Court

Thing that made me curious about after learning was just how long the briefing process takes. The fact that simply one part of a supreme court case takes 104 days is astonishing to my mind. Something that I had been believing incorrectly that was correct this week was that I thought that the judges simply vote, chose people to write briefings and then were done, I was not aware of the many times that different drafts circulated and how long it takes for them to reach a final decision. I also find the whole concept of specialized public agencies intreaging as they are part of the government but not technically one of the three branches.

Some questions I have after this week are is there any part of the government not subject to having their budget approved by the Senate? What cases have been allowed to go over the 30 min. per side mark? Have there been any cases were political bias is very much evident?

Week 4 Post 2 Specialized Federal Agencies and the Process of the Supreme Court


           Countries change and society develops. Beginning in 1887, congress realized this and created the first specialized public agency. Specialized public agencies are multi-tasked agencies. They execute laws passed by Congress in their specialized fields, enact rules and regulations that reflect policy choices, and decide disputes arising among those whom they are empowered to regulate. Some notable agencies contain the Interstate Commerce Commission, the first one created to regulate to nation’s railroads and no longer exists, the Securities and Exchange Commission, created to regulate the stock market during the great depression, and the Federal Election Commission, created after a series of campaign finance scandals. In 1946 Congress, alarmed by the rapid expansion of specialized agencies, passed the Administrative Procedures Act. The Act establishes a process that must be followed when a Cabinet department or a specialized agency issues new regulation. They also must have their budget approved by the Senate.

           The Supreme Court receives around 3,000 cases every year, and only chooses 75 to 80 of these cases. The rules of the court say that the court will use its discretion to grant review very sparingly, only when the issue involves a conflict the lower courts have not been able to resolve or an issue of profound importance that it should be resolved in the final tribunal of the US Supreme Court. Once the court accepts a case the briefing process begins. The briefing process takes place over around 104 days and consists of the different sides writing argument briefs. The court holds hearings with 30 minuets per side, in major cases this might increase. The main function of the oral argument is to shape the justices’ following discussion. A day or two after the hearing the nine justices get together in private and debate the case. A tentative vote is decided, and the first draft opinions are written. These draft opinions circulate amongst colleagues. After a deadline set by the Chief Justice the court announces the opinion if all the justices are ready.

           The court has some external limits on its power. These include: the courts reactive nature, in which they cannot decide an issue not yet brought before them. They cannot conduct any new fact-finding effort and must accept the facts that were developed in the lower courts. They have high respect for past precedent and do not overrule them lightly. The responsibility of the author to craft the decision in such a way that the Justices who appear ready to support the outcome will stick with it rather than break off and write separately, or even dissent.

           When it comes to politics Judges are supposed to avoid making decisions based on their personal policy and moral preferences or desires, as to do so would be contradictory to judicial ethics and to the tradition of judging. However, every judge is a product of their life experience. As people live life, they develop a personal philosophy about the ultimate concerns in life. When it comes to the Justices, we must hop that this includes a enduring concept of justice. The craft of judging will enable a judge, over time, to become aware of his or her personal value system. When that system seems to bear on a given case, the judge will attempt to reconcile it with first principles of law that will guide the way to a decision that can be accepted as just. However, the judicial discipline and habits of the mind that they develop should help the demise of political instinct or at the very least partisan instincts. Therefore, while the judges have political beliefs through life, it is the hope that they can set them aside to judge cases and therefore keep the Courts free of political influences.

Week 4 Post 1 Specialized Federal Agencies and the Process of the Supreme Court



  • Laws represent the choices of the sovereign people of America, acting through their representatives
  • interpretations of the law by the courts tend to be accepted and respected by the people most of the time
  • Congress creates law by legislating
  • President heads the branch that puts those laws into force and gives them real-world meaning
  • Supreme Court and lower courts apply the constitution and the laws to specific legal disputes between real parties
  • Specialized federal agencies
  • Law that emerges from all sources is subject to review elsewhere in government
  • Oversight process can be considered political in the sense that it is a mechanism for ensuring that the huge federal enterprise functions in service of the needs and desires of the sovereign people.
  • Political accountability deals with two categories of federal law: statutory and administrative
  • Statutory Law – law that emerges from Congress
  • Addresses a civic problem or opportunity
  • Most federal laws are not self-enforcing
  • Accountability comes from the political check the people have every time feral elections happen. Also, from courts’ application of judicial review
  • Administrative law – law that has its origin in a source other than Congress, state or local legislative entities Ex: presidential Executive order or proclamation
  • Actions create binging rules of law, do no explicitly create new legal rights
  • AS conditions in America changed, see Industrial Revolution, Congress came to believe that the three branches of government could not effectively handle new social and cultural complexities.
  • Article II anticipated that congress would create “the executive departments”, the president could require those departments to give him their opinions on government policy. The first Congress created executive departments i.e. the Cabinet
  • Beginning in 1887, Congress created a variety of specialized public agencies within the federal government. Based on Article 1 section 8.
  • Multi-tasked agency – execute laws passed by Congress in their specialized fields, enact rules and regulations that reflect policy choices, they decide disputes arising among those whom they are empowered to regulate
  • First specialized agency to come into begin was the Interstate Commerce Commission.
  • Created to regulate the nation’s railroads – no longer exists
  • In response to rail monopolies – highly complex and needed experts – not a cabinet department 
  • Securities and Exchange Commission in 1933 to regulate the stock markets during the great Depression
  • Explosive growth during the FDR administration
  • Federal Election Commission created in 1974 following a series of campaign finance scandals in the 1972 presidential election campaign (Nixon and McGovern)
  • Write rules to implement federal laws governing elections and voting
  • Judges cases involving candidates or organizations that are challenged for allegedly violating one or more federal election laws.
  • Has power to issue advisory opinions on election law questions
  • Administrative Procedures Act
  • 1946 alarmed by rapid expansion congress passed to impose some controls
  • The Act establishes a process that must be followed when a Cabinet department or a specialized agency issues new regulation
  • Usually must be published in draft form, give public opportunity to react to them before they take effect
  • Regulations not permitted if they are not tied directly to a power granted by statutory law to that agency or if they are arbitrary or capricious
  • Regulations are subject to review in the courts when challenged by someone or some entity affected by them
  • Congressional Oversight
  • The work of the President acting directly, the Cabinet departments, and the specialized agencies are supervised by congressional oversight committees. 
  • Must get approval for budgets
  • Many appointments require advice and consent of Senate – conducts public hearings on such nominations – address both personal qualification so the nominees and public discussion and debate of policy issues
  • the President chooses whom to nominate to serve as members of those agencies, subject to the Senate’s advice and consent.  Any member of the President’s Cabinet may be dismissed by the President, at any time, for any reason, or even for no reason at all.  (The people who work within a Cabinet department are protected from arbitrary firing or discipline by federal civil service laws.) The President can also remove some of an agency’s principal officers, but in the case of specialized agencies, removal may be permitted only if those officers have engaged in serious misconduct. 
  • The supreme court 1935 upheld as constitutional congress’s power to create specialized agencies with varying degrees of inferenced from the head of the Executive branch
  • The court denied the president the unqualified power to remove a member of such agency once they were in office
  • Chevron doctrine gives federal courts less power to review the actions of independent agencies if the law creating them and controlling their duties has an ambiguous meaning. Courts are required to defer to the agency’s interpretation of their governing general laws, unless the agency’s view is wrong
  • Auer doctrine gives federal courts less power to review the way the agencies interpret the regulations that they themselves have written to govern their own modes of operation
  • Supreme court process
  • Cases brought to the supreme court
  • Writ of centiorari – telling the lower court, certify your record and send it up because we’re going to review this legal dispute
  • Almost total discretion to say we will or won’t review
  • Review 75 to 80 cases every calendar year – get about 3000 a year
  • The rules of the court say that the court will use its discretion to grant review very sparingly, only when the issue involves a conflict the lower courts have not been able to resolve or an issue of profound importance that it should be resolved in the final tribunal of the US Supreme Court
  • They want to have enough cases that at a minimum in each two-week sitting, when they hold hearings, they will have a minimum of 12 cases. Hold hearings on Monday, Tuesday and Wednesday
  • The lawyers have 104 days to complete the briefing process
  • The side that brought the case files a written brief first, arguing why it should win
  • Then the side that won the case below and want the lower court case to be upheld, files its answering brief
  • And then the one that lost the case below and want the court to overturn the lower court files a reply brief
  • This all normally takes 104 days
  • Then court holds hearing
  • 30 min per side
  • Usually leading counsel start with about 20 min of time and saves time so that they can answer the other side
  • Then the opposing counsel gets up and argues for half an hour
  • In major cases that involve complex issues they will allow the time to run beyond
  • Main function of oral argument is to shape the justices’ following discussion
  • Courts of appeal do not gather any facts, facts are always gathered in the trial court
  • The federal system – federal district court – hold trials call witness, they develop the facts
  • Those facts stay with the case as goes all the way up
  • Supreme court takes the case’s facts as they come to them
  • Day or two after the hearing the nine justices get together in private and debate the case
  • Chief Justice speaks first then each Justice speaks in turn, saying how they will vote on the case, affirm or reverse, get tentative vote on how the case is going to be decided
  • Bases upon that tentative vote they assign a justice to write a draft opinion, if the Chief Justice has voted with, he majority the assigning task is there’s to assign. If the Chief Justice is in the minority the senior justice who is in the majority assigns the drafting of opinion.
  • Draft opinion is written, and it circulates among the colleagues, colleagues then send back note, 
  • Join me – I like the way you have written this opinion and you have my vote to make that the opinion of the court
  • I will write separately – I will wither write a concurring opinion, because the weapons I want to use are different from the reason you have hear, but you have my vote for the result
  • I will dissent – I still disagree
  • I read your majority opinion, I would like to join, but hear are the things I think need to be changed
  • Opinions can change
  • Chief Justice sets deadlines for when he wants to be able to complete the term and all majority opinions must be in by a certain date in June and all concurring or dissenting opinions must be in by a deadline date
  • And then the court announces the opinion
  • But on the way to the bench to announce an opinion any justice can say, I’m not ready yet, and they can call it back
  •  
  •  
  •  
  • External limits on the Court’s powers
  • The Court’s reactive nature – they cannot decide an issue not yet brought before them.
  • The record in the case – they don’t conduct any new fact-finding effort then it has agreed to decide a case. Must accept the facts as they were developed in the lower courts
  • Respect for past precedents – does not lightly overrule precedent but is not forbidden to do so. Overruling may come when a prior ruling has been undermined by changing factual circumstances or changes in legal or constitutional doctrine
  • Constitutional avoidance – even though a constitutional question ah been raised in a given case, that issue will not be decided unless necessary to resolve that case
  • The need to persuade colleagues – the responsibility of the author to craft the decision in such a way that the Justices who appear ready to support the outcome will stick with it rather than break off and write separately, or even dissent.
  •  
  • Judges must avoid making decisions based on their personal policy policy and moral preferences or desires. To do so would be contradictory to judicial ethics and to the tradition of judging – avoid pre-judging the result, be impartial, show respect to argument made in attempt to persuade them
  • Every judge is a product of his or her own life experience
  • People develop personal philosophy about the ultimate concerns in life
  • Hopefully beliefs include an enduring concept of justice
  • The craft of judging will enable a judge, over time, to become aware of his or her personal value system. When that system seems to bear on a given case, the judge will attempt to reconcile it with first principles of law that will guide the way to a decision that can be accepted as just.
  • Bakke case
  • Struck down a system of race-based admissions to the medical school of the University of California
  • Decision 4-1-4
  • One justice – Powell- liked the outcome that the four justices had voted for, but did not like the opinion they wrote
  • Per curiam – label given to a decision given to a decision made by the court but with no author
  • Summary ruling a ruling that resolves a case without the usual arguments by lawyers
  • Bush v Gore
  • Five justices in the majority were justices who had been appointed by Republicans
  • Three of the justices in dissent had been appointed by democrats
  • There are people who believe that the Court made the choice to make George Bush the president because he was a Republican and they were Republicans
  • Thinks it was a constitutional crisis, the court was confronting deadlines for the choice of a new president
  • In 1876 the Court went up to the night before Inauguration Day before a president got settled. (Tilden v Hayes)
  • The judicial displines and the habits of a mind that they develop in doing tent to demise political instinct or at least partisan instincts
  • 36-day dispute
  • Two oral arguments and two decisions
  • Look up blacklidge case – around 1876
  • JOHN T. Jonas v. ALVIN N. BLACKLIDGE?






Professor: Lyle Denniston

University of Baltimore

Monday, February 18, 2019

Week 3 Post 3 Oversight and Personal Bias


The thing that surprised me most from this week was learning about the origins of the supreme court justices. I don’t know where I thought that they came from before, in fact I believe that I thought they simply worked in lower courts, but the fact that they tend to work in other branches makes me wonder how many other things I assume wrong, and how partisan the rulings of the supreme court actually are. Another thing that I should have know was that Congress would control their budget, and I feel disappointment in myself for not thinking that it could be used to control this institution
One of my major questions is what does the Supreme Court use their budget for? Have there been times were the supreme court has been controlled by there budget? Also, how much was Taft’s decisions on the supreme court related to the things he focused on during his presidency?

Week 3 Post 2 Oversight and Personal Bias


           Compared to the Legislative and Executive branches of the government the Judicial branch does not have as many checks and balances. The Justices do not run for election and never answer to the voters in any direct sense. However, there are some ways the court is controlled. One of these ways is impeachment. The Judicial Branch is as controlled by the possibly of impeachment as the others. Legislative action can also affect the Supreme Court. Congress can pass laws to reduce the jurisdiction of the Supreme Court to hear appeals from the lower courts and must also approve the spending of any money by the Supreme Court. Because of this at least once a year a justice must testify before congressional committees to explain and justify the court budget. Lawmakers frequently use those appearances to vent some of their discontent with the Court’s rulings, however congress seldom modifies the Court's budget. The most influential part is the way Judges are nominated. Judges are appointed by the president and confirmed by the Senate, the House has no role, and the arrival of each new Justice always has a significant impact on how the Court performs its functions.

           While the involvement of the Supreme Court in politics might not by cut and dry, no one can deny that the Executive Branch is. Because the Justices themselves are appointed by the Executive Branch, there appointment, and therefore themselves is political. There is also the fact that many of the justices worked in the Executive branch for a justice department. Presidential administrations tend to have policy goals that everyone is affected by, even the lawyers. The Justices then bring that to the court with them. Therefore, the supreme court is not as disassociated from politics as they would like.

Week 3 Post 1 Oversight and Personal Bias


  • If government is meant to serve the people why is there a system in which one of the parts is an institution not chosen by the people, has members who serve for life and has not duty to account to the people directly on how it uses its power
  • Americans have a higher level of trust in the judicial branch than either of the others
  • Only 5 amendment have specially overturned rulings by the court
  • the 13th, abolishing slavery
  • the 14th, guaranteeing legal equality to freed slaves
  • the 19th, giving women the right to vote
  • the 24th, banning poll taxes
  • and the 26th, giving 18, 19 and 20-year-olds the right to vote.
  • Power checks
  • Justices do not run for election
  • Never answer to the votes in any direct sense
  • Constitution amendment
  • Extremely difficult to get the consensus needed
  • Impeachment
  • Impeachment only used once – Samuel chase of Maryland – acquitted
  • Legislative action
  • Congress can pass laws to reduce the jurisdiction of the Supreme court to hear appeals from the lower courts
  • Congress must approve the spending of any money by the supreme court
  • Once a year at lease on justice must testify before congressional committees to explain and justify the court budget
  • lawmakers frequently use those appearances to vent some of their discontent with the Court’s rulings
  • congress selfdoms modify the courts budget
  • Judge nomination
  • Judges are appointed by the president and confirmed by the Senate – House has no role
  • the arrival of each new Justice always has a significant impact on how the Court performs its functions
  • dynamic of decision-making does change
  • the doctrine of the separation of powers requires the judiciary to be independent of the elected branches of government
  • following the rule of law requires judicial independence
  • in order for judges to tread in the service of justice, they must be impartial and fair in deciding cases.
  •  Neither impartiality nor fairness is possible if the judiciary is controlled by another branch.
  • judicial independence"? For starters, it is fair, impartial, and honest adjudication motivated by a commitment to justice and the expression of justice in law
  • the current way to get on the court is to work first in the executive branch for a justice department
  • Ex: Justice Gorsuch, Thomas, Alito, Roberts, Kagan
  • Service in the executive branch tends to make you more ideologically oriented in a partisan sense -working for a president’s administration had distinct policy goals that everyone works for
  • Bring that to the court with you
  • The court has taken over as the guardian of the representative democracy
  • Detached judgement - Ingredients of choice are always present
  • Marbury v Madison – political decision about the power of the court
  • Bush v. Gore, - relied on the Fourteenth Amendment’s equality of rights among voters to settle that year’s presidential election
  • Which branch of the government should be determining the rules of campaign finance
  • Supreme court – know less about politics that any of the other branches
  • Congress – pass laws that will protect their own reelection
  • At its core it is a constitutional question – supreme court or an amendment
  • Because money talks, money is a form of expression protected fully and gradly by the first amendment
  • Do people with experience with politics bring something to the court
  • Yes –
  • Sandra day O’Connor – instincts as a political figure – very important in given her the role of the swing justice
  • Lewis Powell – been in local government and board of schools- also swing justice
  • Tony Kennedy – experience of being a lobbyist before the California legislature so he knew political method and political progress – brings seasoned political perspective
  •  



Professor: Lyle Denniston
University of Baltimore

Week 2 Post 3 Supreme Court and the Beginning of a Nation


My reaction to learning about the articles of Confederacy was shock that they lasted as long as they did, and astonishment at how different they were from the Constitution. I was also curious about what history the founders were thinking about when they thought that factions would take over the government, and amazement at how right they would turn out to be with there fear. I continue to be amazed at how underestimated the Supreme Court was by the Founders. I feel that knowing more about were the Government comes from will help me analyze it later.
The main question on my mind after reading about Rutledge is if any other Supreme Court nominations have been rejected. I also wonder if Rutledge was one of the only people to be appointed during Senate recess. Another wonder was if anyone else spoke out against the Jay Treaty. I also wonder if any other people ruined their carriers like Rutledge did.

Week 2 Post 2 Supreme Court and the Beginning of a Nation



The first attempt the colonies made at governing themselves was the article of confederation. They had one branch of government, congress, with every state having one vote, no matter the size. Citizens of each state would have right to vote for delegates. Each state would be entitled to two to seven delegates, that they could recall and replace at any time they wished but could not serve more than three years in any six-year period. Legislation could pass if at least nine states voted for it and amending the Articles would take a unanimous vote. The Articles of Confederation failed, and the Constitutional Convention convened to fix the government. However, the Founding Fathers feared a popular government, a government were the people themselves exercise a dominant role. They thought that factions would take over the government and use it for their own selfish ends. Because of this they formed a republic, a government made up of representatives chosen by the people. They crafted mechanisms by which the sovereign people choose representatives to carry out the functions of government, rather than having the people themselves directly perform government functions as is done. Three of these articles directly affect the court: Article I sets up the appointing of Justices, Article III of the Constitution created the Supreme Court and gave Congress the authority to create lower federal courts, and Article V creates the process for amending the constitution which must include the proposal of an amendment and its ratification.

           One of the first interaction that court had with politics was with John Rutledge. John Rutledge was a respected man, who had already served a short term on the Supreme Court before resigning. After John Jay resigned from the court Rutledge offered himself to Washington for the position, and he was put on the Court. However, because the Senate was in recess has was only on in a temporary position. On July 16, 1795, Rutledge gave a speech denouncing the Jay Treaty with England, that would end the War of Independence. However, both the President and Senate had already approved the treaty. Because of this and of concerns about his mental stability voted down his nomination 10-14. This established the precedent that there is no guarantee that when a President, however popular the President, makes a nomination to the Supreme Court, that the nominee will be confirmed. It also heavily showed the politics aspect of being appointed to the Supreme Court, as Rutledge’s speech, a very political thing, kept him from getting appointed.


Week 2 Post 1 Supreme Court and the Beginning of a Nation


  • Jamestown
  • among the first things Jamestown voyagers did was conduct an election
  • the commanders of the 105 colonists unsealed a box containing a secret list of the seven men picked in England to be the colony’s council and from among the councilors were to pick a president
  • Articles of Confederation
  • One branch – congress
  • The people of each state had one vote in congress, no matter the size
  • Citizens of each state, (white, male, 21, property owners, no religious oaths) would have right to vote – voting for delegates
  • Power to recall its delegates at any time it wished and send alternates
  • Each state entitled to 2 to 7 delegates
  • No delegate could serve more than three years in any 6-year period
  • Congress is to represent the 13 states, and each state gets one vote in Congress, and legislation can pass if at least nine states vote for it (except that amending the Articles would take a unanimous vote of all 13).
  • all provisions of the original constitution that in any way impact voting or elections
  • Democracy vs. Republic
  • Democracy = people are the government
  • Popular government = people themselves exercise a dominant role – fearsome notion to the Founders
  • Thought that factions would take over government and use for own selfish ends not for the good of the public as a whole – see Shays rebellion
  • Idea for “cure” was a republic
  • Republic - government made up of representatives chosen by the people
  • The sovereign people of the nation, with their ultimate control over who operates the machinery of government on their behalf are both the primary actors in the proper functioning of a republic, and the ultimate guarantors of the continued existence of the Constitution and the government it brought forth
  • they crafted mechanisms by which the sovereign people choose representatives to carry out the functions of government, rather than having the people themselves directly perform government functions as is done
  •  
  • Parts of the Constitution
  • Article 1, Sections 2 through 7
  • Section 2
  • Qualification of who may be elected to the house: supreme court has ruled that added qualifications may not be imposed
  • Outlines how the seats in the House are to be allotted among states according to population – includes 3/5ths clause
  • Each state will have at least one member of the House
  • Governor of a state may call an election to fill a vacancy in the state’s House membership
  • Section 3, creating the Senate
  • All states equal membership – two members – no matter population
  • 1/3 of senator elected every two years – election by the state legislatures, changed in 17th amendments
  • Qualifications to be a senator
  • Describe impeachment, house files, senate try’s
  • Section 4
  • “The times, places and manner of holding elections for senators and representatives shall be prescribed in each state by the legislature thereof; but the Congress may at any time by law make or alter such regulations, except as to the places of choosing senators.” (Constitution)
  •  
  • state legislatures regulate who may vote and how elections are conducted, congress second-guessed for federal, state election laws may not violate the federal constitution
  • Congress is required to meet annually
  • Section 5
  • Gives the House and Senate the authority to determine if an elected member meets the qualifications of the office and was properly elected
  • Section 6
  • assures members of Congress that they will be paid a salary, but bars them from holding any other office in the government.
  • Section 7
  • All bills for raising revenue must begin in the House
  • Presidential veto process + congressional override of vetoes
  • Section 8
  • Duties and powers of Congress
  • Article II, Section 1
  • Creates the office of the President of the United States
  • Term of 4 years
  • Who may hold office?
  • People of America vote for electors, each state gets the number of electors that it has in members of the House and Senate combined
  • The presidential electors chosen by the states meet, on a date specified by Congress, to choose the President. – changed in 12th amendment
  • Describes the selection of a president to fill a vacancy in the office – changed by 25th amendment
  • Salary for the President, bars any reduction of the amount during a President’s service
  • bars the President from receiving financial benefits or gifts from any state
  • Section 2
  • Assigns the president the task of nominating judges and other federal officers
  • Assigns to the Senates the task of advice and consent to said nominees
  • Article III
  • Creates the Supreme Court
  • Gives Congress the authority to create lower federal courts
  • Article IV the federal government will “guarantee to every state in the Union a republican form of government.”
  • Article V
  • sets up amending the Constitution
  • Two alternatives for proposing amendments
  • A proposal approved by a 2/3rds vote in both the House and the Senate
  • A proposal by a convention that has been called by Congress at the request of 2/3 of the states
  • Two alternatives for ratification of a proposed amendment
  • By the legislatures of 3/4s of the states
  • By a convention of 3/4s of the states
  • Article VI
  • Supremacy clause
  • Article VII
  • Constitution would go into effect when nine states had ratified it
  • Those ten amendments dealing with politics are:
  • The Bill of Rights contain noting explicit about voting or election
  • Since the bill of rights 17 additional amendments have been added to the basic document
  • the Twelfth (modifying the mode of presidential election-presidential and vice-presidential candidates are to be elected on separate ballots, the Electors of a state must not vote for two candidates for the two offices if both are from that state, If no presidential candidate wins a majority, the choice goes to the House of Representatives, among the top three vote-getters, and the House votes by states, with each state having one vote. If there is no majority winner among the vice-presidential candidates, the choice goes to the Senate, among the top two vote-getters)
  • the Fourteenth (guaranteeing “due process” and legal equality, with a major impact on voting rights; that Amendment also modifies to a degree the allocation of seats in the House of Representatives – eliminates 3/5ths clause, gives former slaves citizenship, along with equal access to the rights of citizenship
  • the Fifteenth (guaranteeing the right to vote for minorities)
  • the Seventeenth (switching to direct voter election of U.S. Senators, instead of election by state legislatures)
  • the Nineteenth (guaranteeing the right to vote for women)
  • the Twentieth (changing the beginning of presidential terms to assure that the prior president does not stay in office much beyond a new election, provides for replacement of a person elected as president, but who dies before taking office)
  • the Twenty-Second (imposing a two-term limit on the election of a president by the people, acting through the Electoral College)
  • the Twenty-Third (establishing the right of Washington, D.C., voters to elect members of the Electoral College for electing the President and Vice-President, does not give those voters a right to elect full members of the House of Representatives or of the Senate)
  • the Twenty-Fourth (banning a poll tax as a condition for voting in federal elections)
  • the Twenty-Sixth (establishing the right to vote beginning at age 18).
  • Politics
  • These may be thought of as political arrangements as a political act when a community of people creates a government to deal with public affairs.
  • Those who wrote the basic document did not feel a need to deal with the mode of election complaining that would become permanent feature of public life in America
  • Not two political parties by Federalist and Anti-Federalists
  • Federalists – those keenly in favor of a strong national government
  • Anti-Federalists – those keenly in favor of a limited central government and stronger state governments.
  • among the original Constitution’s provisions are those that have provided the principle mechanism by which politics in its party activity sense would continue directly influence the Supreme Court
  • if the Court is subject to political influence in this sense, then its role in superintending American politics will be is affected
  • those provisions are in Articles I and II setting the process by which Justices are named to the Supreme Court and judges named to the lower federal courts
  • Representation
  • the sovereign people of America and their chosen representatives have had an abiding interest in enlarging the political community and protecting the right to vote
  • A person without a vote is, in a real sense, not represented
  •  
  •  
  •  
  • The house was under-representative
  •  various classes of people did not have the right to vote for the members
  •  remained under-representative until non-white, women, and people too poor to pay a poll tax were represented
  •  Constitution did not require the state legislatures in America to be truly representative
  • The basic document left it to the states themselves to decide who would be represented in their legislatures
  • Many states choose to create upper chambers like the Senate - eats representing counties rather than actual populations
  • Not uncommon that in lower chambers with seats “based” on population rural areas were weighted higher that populations would suggest
  • Reflection of the dominance of agriculture in many states
  • Legislators were keen on looking after the interests of the farmers and ranchers
  • also reflected the fact that the urbanization of America occurred without an adjustment of apportionment of seats to keep up with such population shifts
  • John Rutledge
  • Delegate to the Stamp Act congress, First Continental Congress and the Confederation Congress
  • an influential delegate at the convention in Philadelphia
  • a signer of the Constitution
  • Washington named him one of the first members of the Supreme Court – associate justice
  • Attended few court sessions because of illness and resigned in 1791
  • When John Jay resigned Rutledge offered himself to Washington for the position, and the President accepted. – recess appointment
  • He was named to the Court during a Senate recess, so he joined the Court in a temporary position.
  • On July 16, 1795, Rutledge gave a speech denouncing the Jay Treaty with England (end of war of independent)
  • He reportedly said in the speech “that he had rather the President should die than sign that puerile instrument” and that he “preferred war to an adoption of it.”
  • Appeared ignorant of the fact that the President had supported the treaty and the Senate had consented to it
  • Because of this and of concerns about his mental stability voted down his nomination 10-14
  • Established a precedent that there is no guarantee that when a president, however popular the president, makes a nomination to the Supreme Court, that the nominee will be confirmed
  • In turning down Rutledge, the Senate made it clear that an examination of a nominee's qualifications would include his political views. 
Professor: Lyle Denniston
University of Baltimore 


Thursday, February 7, 2019

Week 1 Post 3 Basics of the Supreme Court


My reaction to learning about the history of these things is shock and astonishment. Astonishment from the fact that England has created a complex law system form things as simple as common law and time. The shock came from both how much the judicial branch is a combination of ideas like the executive and supreme court, and how many of the well know powers that it wields today it never was meant to have. I feel that by learning more about the underlying principles of the Supreme Court that I can understand its power as the third branch of the united states better.
After learning more about this topic, the main question on my mind is how are these hugely influential people chosen for the court and how do their decisions effect politics as a whole? Because of this I also wonder if the Judicial branch has managed to maintain the separation from the other branches of the government the founders intended for it to have.

Week 1 Post 2 Basics of the Supreme Court

           When creating the judicial branch of the government the founders drew on many different people and experiences. Two people that had a major influence on them were Sir Edward Coke and Baron de Montesquieu. Sir Edward Coke was an English lawyer, judge, and scholar. His main legacy is the idea of the independence of the judiciary and the principle that judges many overturn statues which are contrary to the fundamental rights. Baron de Montesquieu was a French political theorist who believed that all men given power will abuse it and therefore came up with the bases of the checks and balances that the writers of the constitution used to form the tree branches of government. However, while Montesquieu was concerned with despots the founders were more concerned with the public itself. When writing the constitution, the founders drew from two main experiences, the judicial system under the British, and the absolute failure of the Articles of Confederation. Under the British the colonies had their own courts; however, these courts were overseen by the Judicial Committer of the Privy Council. One thing that angered many colonists during this time was the British governments refusal to allow for life-tenured judges. This became such a point of controversy between the two groups that it was listed as a grievance on the Declaration of Independence. However, once the colonists gained their freedom, the new government, the Articles of Confederation, were weakened by the absence of a central judicial authority, as state courts, the highest level of court, favored their own states laws when conflicts arose.

           Once the constitution was written and the new government was formed most of the judicial system was laid out in Article III. Section 1 of this article highlights the three important facts of the supreme court directly outlines in the constitution: that it was a single court at the apex of the federal judiciary, the justices would serve for life providing good behavior as they were not exempted from the impeachment process, and an assured salary that congress did not have control over. These factors served to help one main aspect of the court, that it was and would always be independent of the other branches of governments, such that the decisions it made would not be affected by possible retaliation. From there the Judiciary act of 1789 created a six-member supreme court plus layers of lower appeal and trail courts in the federal system. One of the main controversies over this new court was the fact that it enhanced the power of the national government at the expense of the states. However as federal authority would be seriously compromised if state courts had the final word on federal constitutional issues, as seen under the Articles of Confederation, this was necessary evil. The Supreme Court was more likely than the state courts to uphold federal power and see to it that the laws and treaties of the United States were uniformly enforced.

           When the constitution was first penned it was widely assumed in early American legal circles that the new courts would follow the practice of English courts in giving legal advice outside the context of specific lawsuits. However, after an incident were George Washington asked for advice on the neutrality stance and the court could not comply it soon became clear that the court was not an executive appendage. This response written by at that time Chief justice John Jay was sighted in later supreme court decisions to strike down federal law commands for federal courts to decide cases that did not involve genuine legal controversy. However, one power that few predicted was judicial review. The Supreme Courts use of judicial review, the power of courts to strike down laws that violate an abiding, fundamental principle of law, came from the 1803 court case Marbury v. Madison. This power has been used several times over the 200 years of the court’s existence on some of the most controversial and remembered decisions.

           The election of 1800 was a landmark election, representing the peaceful passing of power from the Federalists to the Democratic-Republicans. However, out of this passing of power came on of the first interactions between the supreme court, Marbury v. Madison. Marbury v. Madison was the first time in the supreme courts history that they effected american politics directly. By taking a stance they established that they were a force to be reckoned with and that they could have at least some influence over the other branches in this way. While the decision might not have effected American politics in the long run, the fact that they could would be important in the future.

Week 1 - Post 1 Basics of the Supreme Court

Edward Coke
  • 1610 - Sir Edward Coke ruled that even his nation’s Parliament – supreme in all matters legal – could not pass laws that invaded fundamental rights  
  • In America, that idea translated into a power for the courts to strike down laws that were unconstitutional if they were found to violate guaranteed rights.
  • Coke’s principal legacy: the independence of the judiciary and the principle that judges may overturn statutes which are contrary to the Constitution
Baron de Montesquieu
  • Baron de Montesquieu - Spirt of the Laws 1748 "constant experience shows us that every man invested with power is apt to abuse it ... it is necessary from the very nature of things that power should be a check to power."  - checks and balances
  • Legislative power alone should have the power to tax - deprive funding if needed
  • Executive power should have right to veto acts from legislature
  • Legislature should have two houses that check each other
  • The judiciary should be independent restrict itself to applying the laws to particular cases in a fixed and constant manner restrict itself to applying the laws to particular cases in a fixed and consistent manner, so that "the judicial power, so terrible to mankind, … becomes, as it were, invisible", and people "fear the office, but not the magistrate."
  • Montesquieu was most concerned about checking despots - Americas founders formed a national government with the aim of checking the tendencies of the people themselves to organize into rival fractions, each pursuing own selfish interests rather that broader public good.
  • prevent the concentration of power so that no faction could take one department captive and subordinate the others
  • If men were angels, no government would be necessary - James Madison num 55
Before Revolution / British
  • 1787 - Great Britain and the newly independent states had longstanding and complex judicial systems
  • American courts existed but were overseen by the Judicial Committee of the Privy Council
  • British government generally forbade colonies from establishing life-tenured judges, further check on judicial independence - dispute so significant it was listed in the Declaration of Independence
  • British government does not have a written constitution: traditions that have developed through the case law over the centuries and through understanding of what the common law is.
Articles of Confederation
  • Articles of confederation were weakened by the absence of a central judicial authority - state courts favor their own laws when conflicts arose
  • Federalist papers -
    • Num. 22. Hamilton writes “the want of a federal judiciary” was a crowning flaw in Articles of confederation. Because of tendency among man to differ in interpretations of law there must be “one supreme tribunal”
    • Num. 78. Hamilton considered the definitive articulation of what the Founders intended when they chose to create an independent judiciary as one of the three branches of the new national governing structure.  
Founders
  • The Founders in 1787, choosing words to express foundational ideas, providing the framework for a government that would establish and protect that right.
  • The people’s representatives, acting as custodians of that framework in the sense that it lies with them to start the machinery to alter or enlarge the right to vote.
  • And, the Supreme Court, exercising the power to declare what constitutional mandates mean, making it the overseer of the law governing voting and elections.
  • Since 1791, the people’s representatives have added a total of 17 amendments to the Constitution, and ten of those have an explicit or implied effect upon the election system and the right to vote: 12,14,15,17,19,20,22,23,24,26
  • Founders did not fear supreme courts authority as much as the other branches - few anticipated that the Supreme Court would assume for itself the ultimate authority to interpret the meaning of the Constitution
  • Specific provisions from Section 1 of Article III:
  • Single court at the apex of the federal judiciary (Supreme Court)
  • Promise of life tenure (for good behavior-Impeachment possible)
  • A promise of an assured salary, to prevent retaliation for the way the Court and lower federal courts decide cases
  • Judiciary act of 1789 -created a six-member supreme court plus a layer of lower appeals and trial courts in the federal system
  • Section 25 - controversial - explicitly enhanced the power of the national government at the expense of the states - basic fear that stirred opposition to ratification - extenders the judicial power of the united states over the state courts allowed appeals to be brought from the state courts to the supreme court when the case involved the supremacy of the Constitution, a treaty, or a federal law. appeals could be brought if the highest court of a state declared a federal law or treaty unconstitutional, or if it upheld a state law which had been challenged under a federal law, treaty, or the Constitution. Federal authority would have been seriously compromised if state courts had the final word on federal constitutional issues. The Supreme Court was more likely than the state courts to uphold federal power and see to it that the laws and treaties of the United States were uniformly enforced.
Supreme court powers
  • The supreme court has made clear that a federal court has no authority to decide any question unless there is a genuine case or controversy that has arisen. Theoretical or abstract legal disputes cannot be decided by federal courts must be a genuine real-world legal dispute
  • Section 2 also divides up the Supreme Court’s authority between what are called “original” cases and what are called “appeals.” The difference is that an “original” case is tried in the first instance in the Supreme Court itself; those cases do not begin in any lower court. Disputes that involve ambassadors + other public ministers and consuls and disputes between two states. All other cases that reach the supreme court are appeals from decisions by lower courts
  • widely assumed in early American legal circles that the new courts created by the Constitution would follow the practice of English courts in giving legal advice outside the context of specific lawsuits
  • did not give legal advice to the president - court was not an executive appendage
  • Later supreme court decisions rely on jays’ letter to strike down federal law commands for federal courts to decide cases that did not involve genuine legal controversy
  • From the 1793 incident forward the supreme court has never decided any question of law outside the specific context of an actual legal dispute - avoided giving advisory opinions.
Marbury v. Madison
  • 1803 - Marbury v. Madison - if a law confit with the Constitution, the Constitution must prevail.
  • In 1800 Jefferson won election over john Adams. Adams administration attempted to sneak through appointments of several judges. Madison refused to deliver official papers to the new judges. One of the failed deliveries was that of William Marbury appointed to be a justice of the peace. Marbury went directly to supreme court seeking a writ of mandamus for Madison to deliver their judgeships. writ of mandamus – a judicial order to compel someone to carry out a duty imposed upon them.
  • Part of the judiciary act of 1789 congress had given the authority to the supreme court to issue such a writ as a matter of original jurisdiction.
  • Court ruling - Feb 24 - had a right to his commission, because President Adams had validly named him to a judgeship, the Senate had confirmed that appointment, the President had signed a commission, and it had been recorded and had the United States seal affixed.  That completed the process, so it made no difference that the commission was not delivered.
  • For every legal wrong there must be a remedy -> Marbury was entitled to a remedy, if one were available under the law
  • This possibility was a question of the law for the courts to decide, not the executive branch, they had completed the role in arranging a judgeship for him.
  • Article III did not include issuing mandamus writs as one of the “original” powers of the Supreme Court.
  • The Constitution is either a superior, paramount law, unchangeable by ordinary means, or it is on a level with ordinary legislative acts, and, like other acts, is alterable when the legislature shall please to alter it
  • William Marbury thus did not get a writ of mandamus, or the judgeship which Adams had arranged for him.
Judicial review
  • Judicial review - is within the power of courts to strike down laws that violate an abiding, fundamental principle of law.
  • Article VI - supremacy clause - constitution is supreme law of the land
  • Article III: judges will interpret the conformity of laws to the supreme law of the land
  • The power of judicial review has been used by this court regularly and frequently over the time of its existence of more than 200 years.

  • EX
    • in 1954 struck down the racial segregation of public schools.
    • In 1967 it struck down a law in Virginia that barred people from marrying a person of the other race.
    • In 1971 it ruled that the government could not prevent the publication by newspapers of the Pentagon Papers.
    • In 1971, in a case from Idaho, it ruled for the first time in history that the doctrine of legal equality under the Constitution protects women from discrimination based upon their sex.
    • the principle that the Constitution provides full equality for gay and lesbian people to marry.
Other
  • In 1995 Supreme Court said that states cannot add to the qualifications for getting elected to the house.
  • Decision 5-to-4.
  • Majority used series of arguments the relationship between the national government and the people directly, the design of the Constitution in seeking to make members of the House the choice of the people, the text of the actual qualifications, and the limited capacity of the states to dictate the nature of the House.
  • Dissenters said the Constitution is silent on the matter, so the states were not forbidden to pursue a change they thought was a proper reform measure.
  • In another time, with a different set of Justices, the result might have come out differently


Professor: Lyle Denniston
University of Baltimore 

Week 11 Post 3 TED Talk Reviews

     I am surprised that there is so little democracy in the election process. I am also intrigued by how long the American brand of constit...