Monday, February 25, 2019

Week 4 Post 2 Specialized Federal Agencies and the Process of the Supreme Court


           Countries change and society develops. Beginning in 1887, congress realized this and created the first specialized public agency. Specialized public agencies are multi-tasked agencies. They execute laws passed by Congress in their specialized fields, enact rules and regulations that reflect policy choices, and decide disputes arising among those whom they are empowered to regulate. Some notable agencies contain the Interstate Commerce Commission, the first one created to regulate to nation’s railroads and no longer exists, the Securities and Exchange Commission, created to regulate the stock market during the great depression, and the Federal Election Commission, created after a series of campaign finance scandals. In 1946 Congress, alarmed by the rapid expansion of specialized agencies, passed the Administrative Procedures Act. The Act establishes a process that must be followed when a Cabinet department or a specialized agency issues new regulation. They also must have their budget approved by the Senate.

           The Supreme Court receives around 3,000 cases every year, and only chooses 75 to 80 of these cases. The rules of the court say that the court will use its discretion to grant review very sparingly, only when the issue involves a conflict the lower courts have not been able to resolve or an issue of profound importance that it should be resolved in the final tribunal of the US Supreme Court. Once the court accepts a case the briefing process begins. The briefing process takes place over around 104 days and consists of the different sides writing argument briefs. The court holds hearings with 30 minuets per side, in major cases this might increase. The main function of the oral argument is to shape the justices’ following discussion. A day or two after the hearing the nine justices get together in private and debate the case. A tentative vote is decided, and the first draft opinions are written. These draft opinions circulate amongst colleagues. After a deadline set by the Chief Justice the court announces the opinion if all the justices are ready.

           The court has some external limits on its power. These include: the courts reactive nature, in which they cannot decide an issue not yet brought before them. They cannot conduct any new fact-finding effort and must accept the facts that were developed in the lower courts. They have high respect for past precedent and do not overrule them lightly. The responsibility of the author to craft the decision in such a way that the Justices who appear ready to support the outcome will stick with it rather than break off and write separately, or even dissent.

           When it comes to politics Judges are supposed to avoid making decisions based on their personal policy and moral preferences or desires, as to do so would be contradictory to judicial ethics and to the tradition of judging. However, every judge is a product of their life experience. As people live life, they develop a personal philosophy about the ultimate concerns in life. When it comes to the Justices, we must hop that this includes a enduring concept of justice. The craft of judging will enable a judge, over time, to become aware of his or her personal value system. When that system seems to bear on a given case, the judge will attempt to reconcile it with first principles of law that will guide the way to a decision that can be accepted as just. However, the judicial discipline and habits of the mind that they develop should help the demise of political instinct or at the very least partisan instincts. Therefore, while the judges have political beliefs through life, it is the hope that they can set them aside to judge cases and therefore keep the Courts free of political influences.

1 comment:

  1. During confirmation hearings, do you think the elected representatives ask questions that help shed light on if life experiences will or could cloud a Justices judgement or are the questions more politically motivated?

    ReplyDelete

Week 11 Post 3 TED Talk Reviews

     I am surprised that there is so little democracy in the election process. I am also intrigued by how long the American brand of constit...