Monday, February 25, 2019

Week 4 Post 1 Specialized Federal Agencies and the Process of the Supreme Court



  • Laws represent the choices of the sovereign people of America, acting through their representatives
  • interpretations of the law by the courts tend to be accepted and respected by the people most of the time
  • Congress creates law by legislating
  • President heads the branch that puts those laws into force and gives them real-world meaning
  • Supreme Court and lower courts apply the constitution and the laws to specific legal disputes between real parties
  • Specialized federal agencies
  • Law that emerges from all sources is subject to review elsewhere in government
  • Oversight process can be considered political in the sense that it is a mechanism for ensuring that the huge federal enterprise functions in service of the needs and desires of the sovereign people.
  • Political accountability deals with two categories of federal law: statutory and administrative
  • Statutory Law – law that emerges from Congress
  • Addresses a civic problem or opportunity
  • Most federal laws are not self-enforcing
  • Accountability comes from the political check the people have every time feral elections happen. Also, from courts’ application of judicial review
  • Administrative law – law that has its origin in a source other than Congress, state or local legislative entities Ex: presidential Executive order or proclamation
  • Actions create binging rules of law, do no explicitly create new legal rights
  • AS conditions in America changed, see Industrial Revolution, Congress came to believe that the three branches of government could not effectively handle new social and cultural complexities.
  • Article II anticipated that congress would create “the executive departments”, the president could require those departments to give him their opinions on government policy. The first Congress created executive departments i.e. the Cabinet
  • Beginning in 1887, Congress created a variety of specialized public agencies within the federal government. Based on Article 1 section 8.
  • Multi-tasked agency – execute laws passed by Congress in their specialized fields, enact rules and regulations that reflect policy choices, they decide disputes arising among those whom they are empowered to regulate
  • First specialized agency to come into begin was the Interstate Commerce Commission.
  • Created to regulate the nation’s railroads – no longer exists
  • In response to rail monopolies – highly complex and needed experts – not a cabinet department 
  • Securities and Exchange Commission in 1933 to regulate the stock markets during the great Depression
  • Explosive growth during the FDR administration
  • Federal Election Commission created in 1974 following a series of campaign finance scandals in the 1972 presidential election campaign (Nixon and McGovern)
  • Write rules to implement federal laws governing elections and voting
  • Judges cases involving candidates or organizations that are challenged for allegedly violating one or more federal election laws.
  • Has power to issue advisory opinions on election law questions
  • Administrative Procedures Act
  • 1946 alarmed by rapid expansion congress passed to impose some controls
  • The Act establishes a process that must be followed when a Cabinet department or a specialized agency issues new regulation
  • Usually must be published in draft form, give public opportunity to react to them before they take effect
  • Regulations not permitted if they are not tied directly to a power granted by statutory law to that agency or if they are arbitrary or capricious
  • Regulations are subject to review in the courts when challenged by someone or some entity affected by them
  • Congressional Oversight
  • The work of the President acting directly, the Cabinet departments, and the specialized agencies are supervised by congressional oversight committees. 
  • Must get approval for budgets
  • Many appointments require advice and consent of Senate – conducts public hearings on such nominations – address both personal qualification so the nominees and public discussion and debate of policy issues
  • the President chooses whom to nominate to serve as members of those agencies, subject to the Senate’s advice and consent.  Any member of the President’s Cabinet may be dismissed by the President, at any time, for any reason, or even for no reason at all.  (The people who work within a Cabinet department are protected from arbitrary firing or discipline by federal civil service laws.) The President can also remove some of an agency’s principal officers, but in the case of specialized agencies, removal may be permitted only if those officers have engaged in serious misconduct. 
  • The supreme court 1935 upheld as constitutional congress’s power to create specialized agencies with varying degrees of inferenced from the head of the Executive branch
  • The court denied the president the unqualified power to remove a member of such agency once they were in office
  • Chevron doctrine gives federal courts less power to review the actions of independent agencies if the law creating them and controlling their duties has an ambiguous meaning. Courts are required to defer to the agency’s interpretation of their governing general laws, unless the agency’s view is wrong
  • Auer doctrine gives federal courts less power to review the way the agencies interpret the regulations that they themselves have written to govern their own modes of operation
  • Supreme court process
  • Cases brought to the supreme court
  • Writ of centiorari – telling the lower court, certify your record and send it up because we’re going to review this legal dispute
  • Almost total discretion to say we will or won’t review
  • Review 75 to 80 cases every calendar year – get about 3000 a year
  • The rules of the court say that the court will use its discretion to grant review very sparingly, only when the issue involves a conflict the lower courts have not been able to resolve or an issue of profound importance that it should be resolved in the final tribunal of the US Supreme Court
  • They want to have enough cases that at a minimum in each two-week sitting, when they hold hearings, they will have a minimum of 12 cases. Hold hearings on Monday, Tuesday and Wednesday
  • The lawyers have 104 days to complete the briefing process
  • The side that brought the case files a written brief first, arguing why it should win
  • Then the side that won the case below and want the lower court case to be upheld, files its answering brief
  • And then the one that lost the case below and want the court to overturn the lower court files a reply brief
  • This all normally takes 104 days
  • Then court holds hearing
  • 30 min per side
  • Usually leading counsel start with about 20 min of time and saves time so that they can answer the other side
  • Then the opposing counsel gets up and argues for half an hour
  • In major cases that involve complex issues they will allow the time to run beyond
  • Main function of oral argument is to shape the justices’ following discussion
  • Courts of appeal do not gather any facts, facts are always gathered in the trial court
  • The federal system – federal district court – hold trials call witness, they develop the facts
  • Those facts stay with the case as goes all the way up
  • Supreme court takes the case’s facts as they come to them
  • Day or two after the hearing the nine justices get together in private and debate the case
  • Chief Justice speaks first then each Justice speaks in turn, saying how they will vote on the case, affirm or reverse, get tentative vote on how the case is going to be decided
  • Bases upon that tentative vote they assign a justice to write a draft opinion, if the Chief Justice has voted with, he majority the assigning task is there’s to assign. If the Chief Justice is in the minority the senior justice who is in the majority assigns the drafting of opinion.
  • Draft opinion is written, and it circulates among the colleagues, colleagues then send back note, 
  • Join me – I like the way you have written this opinion and you have my vote to make that the opinion of the court
  • I will write separately – I will wither write a concurring opinion, because the weapons I want to use are different from the reason you have hear, but you have my vote for the result
  • I will dissent – I still disagree
  • I read your majority opinion, I would like to join, but hear are the things I think need to be changed
  • Opinions can change
  • Chief Justice sets deadlines for when he wants to be able to complete the term and all majority opinions must be in by a certain date in June and all concurring or dissenting opinions must be in by a deadline date
  • And then the court announces the opinion
  • But on the way to the bench to announce an opinion any justice can say, I’m not ready yet, and they can call it back
  •  
  •  
  •  
  • External limits on the Court’s powers
  • The Court’s reactive nature – they cannot decide an issue not yet brought before them.
  • The record in the case – they don’t conduct any new fact-finding effort then it has agreed to decide a case. Must accept the facts as they were developed in the lower courts
  • Respect for past precedents – does not lightly overrule precedent but is not forbidden to do so. Overruling may come when a prior ruling has been undermined by changing factual circumstances or changes in legal or constitutional doctrine
  • Constitutional avoidance – even though a constitutional question ah been raised in a given case, that issue will not be decided unless necessary to resolve that case
  • The need to persuade colleagues – the responsibility of the author to craft the decision in such a way that the Justices who appear ready to support the outcome will stick with it rather than break off and write separately, or even dissent.
  •  
  • Judges must avoid making decisions based on their personal policy policy and moral preferences or desires. To do so would be contradictory to judicial ethics and to the tradition of judging – avoid pre-judging the result, be impartial, show respect to argument made in attempt to persuade them
  • Every judge is a product of his or her own life experience
  • People develop personal philosophy about the ultimate concerns in life
  • Hopefully beliefs include an enduring concept of justice
  • The craft of judging will enable a judge, over time, to become aware of his or her personal value system. When that system seems to bear on a given case, the judge will attempt to reconcile it with first principles of law that will guide the way to a decision that can be accepted as just.
  • Bakke case
  • Struck down a system of race-based admissions to the medical school of the University of California
  • Decision 4-1-4
  • One justice – Powell- liked the outcome that the four justices had voted for, but did not like the opinion they wrote
  • Per curiam – label given to a decision given to a decision made by the court but with no author
  • Summary ruling a ruling that resolves a case without the usual arguments by lawyers
  • Bush v Gore
  • Five justices in the majority were justices who had been appointed by Republicans
  • Three of the justices in dissent had been appointed by democrats
  • There are people who believe that the Court made the choice to make George Bush the president because he was a Republican and they were Republicans
  • Thinks it was a constitutional crisis, the court was confronting deadlines for the choice of a new president
  • In 1876 the Court went up to the night before Inauguration Day before a president got settled. (Tilden v Hayes)
  • The judicial displines and the habits of a mind that they develop in doing tent to demise political instinct or at least partisan instincts
  • 36-day dispute
  • Two oral arguments and two decisions
  • Look up blacklidge case – around 1876
  • JOHN T. Jonas v. ALVIN N. BLACKLIDGE?






Professor: Lyle Denniston

University of Baltimore

2 comments:

  1. Great notes. Are you thinking of being a lawyer?

    ReplyDelete
  2. Not at this moment. Currently STEM subjects interest me more!

    ReplyDelete

Week 11 Post 3 TED Talk Reviews

     I am surprised that there is so little democracy in the election process. I am also intrigued by how long the American brand of constit...