The first attempt the colonies made at governing themselves was the article of confederation. They had one branch of government, congress, with every state having one vote, no matter the size. Citizens of each state would have right to vote for delegates. Each state would be entitled to two to seven delegates, that they could recall and replace at any time they wished but could not serve more than three years in any six-year period. Legislation could pass if at least nine states voted for it and amending the Articles would take a unanimous vote. The Articles of Confederation failed, and the Constitutional Convention convened to fix the government. However, the Founding Fathers feared a popular government, a government were the people themselves exercise a dominant role. They thought that factions would take over the government and use it for their own selfish ends. Because of this they formed a republic, a government made up of representatives chosen by the people. They crafted mechanisms by which the sovereign people choose representatives to carry out the functions of government, rather than having the people themselves directly perform government functions as is done. Three of these articles directly affect the court: Article I sets up the appointing of Justices, Article III of the Constitution created the Supreme Court and gave Congress the authority to create lower federal courts, and Article V creates the process for amending the constitution which must include the proposal of an amendment and its ratification.
One of the first
interaction that court had with politics was with John Rutledge. John Rutledge
was a respected man, who had already served a short term on the Supreme Court
before resigning. After John Jay resigned from the court Rutledge offered
himself to Washington for the position, and he was put on the Court. However,
because the Senate was in recess has was only on in a temporary position. On
July 16, 1795, Rutledge gave a speech denouncing the Jay Treaty with England,
that would end the War of Independence. However, both the President and Senate
had already approved the treaty. Because of this and of concerns about his
mental stability voted down his nomination 10-14. This established the
precedent that there is no guarantee that when a President, however popular the
President, makes a nomination to the Supreme Court, that the nominee will be
confirmed. It also heavily showed the politics aspect of being appointed to the
Supreme Court, as Rutledge’s speech, a very political thing, kept him from
getting appointed.
What are your thoughts of Justices as political beings?
ReplyDeleteI believe that as there job is to be unbiased, they should be allowed to have political opinions but that they should not effect there decisions. The decisions should be based on the Constitution not political opinions. However, they do have opinions on how they should do there job and that in its self makes them political beings.
ReplyDelete