- Jamestown
- among the first things Jamestown voyagers did was conduct an election
- the commanders of the 105 colonists unsealed a box containing a secret list of the seven men picked in England to be the colony’s council and from among the councilors were to pick a president
- Articles of Confederation
- One branch – congress
- The people of each state had one vote in congress, no matter the size
- Citizens of each state, (white, male, 21, property owners, no religious oaths) would have right to vote – voting for delegates
- Power to recall its delegates at any time it wished and send alternates
- Each state entitled to 2 to 7 delegates
- No delegate could serve more than three years in any 6-year period
- Congress is to represent the 13 states, and each state gets one vote in Congress, and legislation can pass if at least nine states vote for it (except that amending the Articles would take a unanimous vote of all 13).
- all provisions of the original constitution that in any way impact voting or elections
- Democracy vs. Republic
- Democracy = people are the government
- Popular government = people themselves exercise a dominant role – fearsome notion to the Founders
- Thought that factions would take over government and use for own selfish ends not for the good of the public as a whole – see Shays rebellion
- Idea for “cure” was a republic
- Republic - government made up of representatives chosen by the people
- The sovereign people of the nation, with their ultimate control over who operates the machinery of government on their behalf are both the primary actors in the proper functioning of a republic, and the ultimate guarantors of the continued existence of the Constitution and the government it brought forth
- they crafted mechanisms by which the sovereign people choose representatives to carry out the functions of government, rather than having the people themselves directly perform government functions as is done
- Parts of the Constitution
- Article 1, Sections 2 through 7
- Section 2
- Qualification of who may be elected to the house: supreme court has ruled that added qualifications may not be imposed
- Outlines how the seats in the House are to be allotted among states according to population – includes 3/5ths clause
- Each state will have at least one member of the House
- Governor of a state may call an election to fill a vacancy in the state’s House membership
- Section 3, creating the Senate
- All states equal membership – two members – no matter population
- 1/3 of senator elected every two years – election by the state legislatures, changed in 17th amendments
- Qualifications to be a senator
- Describe impeachment, house files, senate try’s
- Section 4
- “The times, places and manner of holding elections for senators and representatives shall be prescribed in each state by the legislature thereof; but the Congress may at any time by law make or alter such regulations, except as to the places of choosing senators.” (Constitution)
- state legislatures regulate who may vote and how elections are conducted, congress second-guessed for federal, state election laws may not violate the federal constitution
- Congress is required to meet annually
- Section 5
- Gives the House and Senate the authority to determine if an elected member meets the qualifications of the office and was properly elected
- Section 6
- assures members of Congress that they will be paid a salary, but bars them from holding any other office in the government.
- Section 7
- All bills for raising revenue must begin in the House
- Presidential veto process + congressional override of vetoes
- Section 8
- Duties and powers of Congress
- Article II, Section 1
- Creates the office of the President of the United States
- Term of 4 years
- Who may hold office?
- People of America vote for electors, each state gets the number of electors that it has in members of the House and Senate combined
- The presidential electors chosen by the states meet, on a date specified by Congress, to choose the President. – changed in 12th amendment
- Describes the selection of a president to fill a vacancy in the office – changed by 25th amendment
- Salary for the President, bars any reduction of the amount during a President’s service
- bars the President from receiving financial benefits or gifts from any state
- Section 2
- Assigns the president the task of nominating judges and other federal officers
- Assigns to the Senates the task of advice and consent to said nominees
- Article III
- Creates the Supreme Court
- Gives Congress the authority to create lower federal courts
- Article IV the federal government will “guarantee to every state in the Union a republican form of government.”
- Article V
- sets up amending the Constitution
- Two alternatives for proposing amendments
- A proposal approved by a 2/3rds vote in both the House and the Senate
- A proposal by a convention that has been called by Congress at the request of 2/3 of the states
- Two alternatives for ratification of a proposed amendment
- By the legislatures of 3/4s of the states
- By a convention of 3/4s of the states
- Article VI
- Supremacy clause
- Article VII
- Constitution would go into effect when nine states had ratified it
- Those ten amendments dealing with politics are:
- The Bill of Rights contain noting explicit about voting or election
- Since the bill of rights 17 additional amendments have been added to the basic document
- the Twelfth (modifying the mode of presidential election-presidential and vice-presidential candidates are to be elected on separate ballots, the Electors of a state must not vote for two candidates for the two offices if both are from that state, If no presidential candidate wins a majority, the choice goes to the House of Representatives, among the top three vote-getters, and the House votes by states, with each state having one vote. If there is no majority winner among the vice-presidential candidates, the choice goes to the Senate, among the top two vote-getters)
- the Fourteenth (guaranteeing “due process” and legal equality, with a major impact on voting rights; that Amendment also modifies to a degree the allocation of seats in the House of Representatives – eliminates 3/5ths clause, gives former slaves citizenship, along with equal access to the rights of citizenship
- the Fifteenth (guaranteeing the right to vote for minorities)
- the Seventeenth (switching to direct voter election of U.S. Senators, instead of election by state legislatures)
- the Nineteenth (guaranteeing the right to vote for women)
- the Twentieth (changing the beginning of presidential terms to assure that the prior president does not stay in office much beyond a new election, provides for replacement of a person elected as president, but who dies before taking office)
- the Twenty-Second (imposing a two-term limit on the election of a president by the people, acting through the Electoral College)
- the Twenty-Third (establishing the right of Washington, D.C., voters to elect members of the Electoral College for electing the President and Vice-President, does not give those voters a right to elect full members of the House of Representatives or of the Senate)
- the Twenty-Fourth (banning a poll tax as a condition for voting in federal elections)
- the Twenty-Sixth (establishing the right to vote beginning at age 18).
- Politics
- These may be thought of as political arrangements as a political act when a community of people creates a government to deal with public affairs.
- Those who wrote the basic document did not feel a need to deal with the mode of election complaining that would become permanent feature of public life in America
- Not two political parties by Federalist and Anti-Federalists
- Federalists – those keenly in favor of a strong national government
- Anti-Federalists – those keenly in favor of a limited central government and stronger state governments.
- among the original Constitution’s provisions are those that have provided the principle mechanism by which politics in its party activity sense would continue directly influence the Supreme Court
- if the Court is subject to political influence in this sense, then its role in superintending American politics will be is affected
- those provisions are in Articles I and II setting the process by which Justices are named to the Supreme Court and judges named to the lower federal courts
- Representation
- the sovereign people of America and their chosen representatives have had an abiding interest in enlarging the political community and protecting the right to vote
- A person without a vote is, in a real sense, not represented
- The house was under-representative
- various classes of people did not have the right to vote for the members
- remained under-representative until non-white, women, and people too poor to pay a poll tax were represented
- Constitution did not require the state legislatures in America to be truly representative
- The basic document left it to the states themselves to decide who would be represented in their legislatures
- Many states choose to create upper chambers like the Senate - eats representing counties rather than actual populations
- Not uncommon that in lower chambers with seats “based” on population rural areas were weighted higher that populations would suggest
- Reflection of the dominance of agriculture in many states
- Legislators were keen on looking after the interests of the farmers and ranchers
- also reflected the fact that the urbanization of America occurred without an adjustment of apportionment of seats to keep up with such population shifts
- John Rutledge
- Delegate to the Stamp Act congress, First Continental Congress and the Confederation Congress
- an influential delegate at the convention in Philadelphia
- a signer of the Constitution
- Washington named him one of the first members of the Supreme Court – associate justice
- Attended few court sessions because of illness and resigned in 1791
- When John Jay resigned Rutledge offered himself to Washington for the position, and the President accepted. – recess appointment
- He was named to the Court during a Senate recess, so he joined the Court in a temporary position.
- On July 16, 1795, Rutledge gave a speech denouncing the Jay Treaty with England (end of war of independent)
- He reportedly said in the speech “that he had rather the President should die than sign that puerile instrument” and that he “preferred war to an adoption of it.”
- Appeared ignorant of the fact that the President had supported the treaty and the Senate had consented to it
- Because of this and of concerns about his mental stability voted down his nomination 10-14
- Established a precedent that there is no guarantee that when a president, however popular the president, makes a nomination to the Supreme Court, that the nominee will be confirmed
- In turning down Rutledge, the Senate made it clear that an examination of a nominee's qualifications would include his political views.
Professor: Lyle Denniston
University of Baltimore
University of Baltimore
Great notes. Are you organizing them in a way that they will be easily accessible later for use?
ReplyDeleteI am saving them all on my computer if this is what you are asking.
ReplyDelete