Compared to the Legislative and Executive branches of the
government the Judicial branch does not have as many checks and balances. The Justices
do not run for election and never answer to the voters in any direct sense. However,
there are some ways the court is controlled. One of these ways is impeachment. The
Judicial Branch is as controlled by the possibly of impeachment as the others.
Legislative action can also affect the Supreme Court. Congress can pass laws to
reduce the jurisdiction of the Supreme Court to hear appeals from the lower courts
and must also approve the spending of any money by the Supreme Court. Because
of this at least once a year a justice must testify before congressional
committees to explain and justify the court budget. Lawmakers frequently use
those appearances to vent some of their discontent with the Court’s rulings,
however congress seldom modifies the Court's budget. The most influential part is
the way Judges are nominated. Judges are appointed by the president and confirmed
by the Senate, the House has no role, and the arrival of each new Justice
always has a significant impact on how the Court performs its functions.
While the involvement of the Supreme Court in politics might
not by cut and dry, no one can deny that the Executive Branch is. Because the Justices
themselves are appointed by the Executive Branch, there appointment, and therefore
themselves is political. There is also the fact that many of the justices
worked in the Executive branch for a justice department. Presidential administrations
tend to have policy goals that everyone is affected by, even the lawyers. The Justices
then bring that to the court with them. Therefore, the supreme court is not as disassociated
from politics as they would like.
What do propose would be an adequate from of checks and balances on the Supreme Court?
ReplyDelete