Thursday, February 7, 2019

Week 1 - Post 1 Basics of the Supreme Court

Edward Coke
  • 1610 - Sir Edward Coke ruled that even his nation’s Parliament – supreme in all matters legal – could not pass laws that invaded fundamental rights  
  • In America, that idea translated into a power for the courts to strike down laws that were unconstitutional if they were found to violate guaranteed rights.
  • Coke’s principal legacy: the independence of the judiciary and the principle that judges may overturn statutes which are contrary to the Constitution
Baron de Montesquieu
  • Baron de Montesquieu - Spirt of the Laws 1748 "constant experience shows us that every man invested with power is apt to abuse it ... it is necessary from the very nature of things that power should be a check to power."  - checks and balances
  • Legislative power alone should have the power to tax - deprive funding if needed
  • Executive power should have right to veto acts from legislature
  • Legislature should have two houses that check each other
  • The judiciary should be independent restrict itself to applying the laws to particular cases in a fixed and constant manner restrict itself to applying the laws to particular cases in a fixed and consistent manner, so that "the judicial power, so terrible to mankind, … becomes, as it were, invisible", and people "fear the office, but not the magistrate."
  • Montesquieu was most concerned about checking despots - Americas founders formed a national government with the aim of checking the tendencies of the people themselves to organize into rival fractions, each pursuing own selfish interests rather that broader public good.
  • prevent the concentration of power so that no faction could take one department captive and subordinate the others
  • If men were angels, no government would be necessary - James Madison num 55
Before Revolution / British
  • 1787 - Great Britain and the newly independent states had longstanding and complex judicial systems
  • American courts existed but were overseen by the Judicial Committee of the Privy Council
  • British government generally forbade colonies from establishing life-tenured judges, further check on judicial independence - dispute so significant it was listed in the Declaration of Independence
  • British government does not have a written constitution: traditions that have developed through the case law over the centuries and through understanding of what the common law is.
Articles of Confederation
  • Articles of confederation were weakened by the absence of a central judicial authority - state courts favor their own laws when conflicts arose
  • Federalist papers -
    • Num. 22. Hamilton writes “the want of a federal judiciary” was a crowning flaw in Articles of confederation. Because of tendency among man to differ in interpretations of law there must be “one supreme tribunal”
    • Num. 78. Hamilton considered the definitive articulation of what the Founders intended when they chose to create an independent judiciary as one of the three branches of the new national governing structure.  
Founders
  • The Founders in 1787, choosing words to express foundational ideas, providing the framework for a government that would establish and protect that right.
  • The people’s representatives, acting as custodians of that framework in the sense that it lies with them to start the machinery to alter or enlarge the right to vote.
  • And, the Supreme Court, exercising the power to declare what constitutional mandates mean, making it the overseer of the law governing voting and elections.
  • Since 1791, the people’s representatives have added a total of 17 amendments to the Constitution, and ten of those have an explicit or implied effect upon the election system and the right to vote: 12,14,15,17,19,20,22,23,24,26
  • Founders did not fear supreme courts authority as much as the other branches - few anticipated that the Supreme Court would assume for itself the ultimate authority to interpret the meaning of the Constitution
  • Specific provisions from Section 1 of Article III:
  • Single court at the apex of the federal judiciary (Supreme Court)
  • Promise of life tenure (for good behavior-Impeachment possible)
  • A promise of an assured salary, to prevent retaliation for the way the Court and lower federal courts decide cases
  • Judiciary act of 1789 -created a six-member supreme court plus a layer of lower appeals and trial courts in the federal system
  • Section 25 - controversial - explicitly enhanced the power of the national government at the expense of the states - basic fear that stirred opposition to ratification - extenders the judicial power of the united states over the state courts allowed appeals to be brought from the state courts to the supreme court when the case involved the supremacy of the Constitution, a treaty, or a federal law. appeals could be brought if the highest court of a state declared a federal law or treaty unconstitutional, or if it upheld a state law which had been challenged under a federal law, treaty, or the Constitution. Federal authority would have been seriously compromised if state courts had the final word on federal constitutional issues. The Supreme Court was more likely than the state courts to uphold federal power and see to it that the laws and treaties of the United States were uniformly enforced.
Supreme court powers
  • The supreme court has made clear that a federal court has no authority to decide any question unless there is a genuine case or controversy that has arisen. Theoretical or abstract legal disputes cannot be decided by federal courts must be a genuine real-world legal dispute
  • Section 2 also divides up the Supreme Court’s authority between what are called “original” cases and what are called “appeals.” The difference is that an “original” case is tried in the first instance in the Supreme Court itself; those cases do not begin in any lower court. Disputes that involve ambassadors + other public ministers and consuls and disputes between two states. All other cases that reach the supreme court are appeals from decisions by lower courts
  • widely assumed in early American legal circles that the new courts created by the Constitution would follow the practice of English courts in giving legal advice outside the context of specific lawsuits
  • did not give legal advice to the president - court was not an executive appendage
  • Later supreme court decisions rely on jays’ letter to strike down federal law commands for federal courts to decide cases that did not involve genuine legal controversy
  • From the 1793 incident forward the supreme court has never decided any question of law outside the specific context of an actual legal dispute - avoided giving advisory opinions.
Marbury v. Madison
  • 1803 - Marbury v. Madison - if a law confit with the Constitution, the Constitution must prevail.
  • In 1800 Jefferson won election over john Adams. Adams administration attempted to sneak through appointments of several judges. Madison refused to deliver official papers to the new judges. One of the failed deliveries was that of William Marbury appointed to be a justice of the peace. Marbury went directly to supreme court seeking a writ of mandamus for Madison to deliver their judgeships. writ of mandamus – a judicial order to compel someone to carry out a duty imposed upon them.
  • Part of the judiciary act of 1789 congress had given the authority to the supreme court to issue such a writ as a matter of original jurisdiction.
  • Court ruling - Feb 24 - had a right to his commission, because President Adams had validly named him to a judgeship, the Senate had confirmed that appointment, the President had signed a commission, and it had been recorded and had the United States seal affixed.  That completed the process, so it made no difference that the commission was not delivered.
  • For every legal wrong there must be a remedy -> Marbury was entitled to a remedy, if one were available under the law
  • This possibility was a question of the law for the courts to decide, not the executive branch, they had completed the role in arranging a judgeship for him.
  • Article III did not include issuing mandamus writs as one of the “original” powers of the Supreme Court.
  • The Constitution is either a superior, paramount law, unchangeable by ordinary means, or it is on a level with ordinary legislative acts, and, like other acts, is alterable when the legislature shall please to alter it
  • William Marbury thus did not get a writ of mandamus, or the judgeship which Adams had arranged for him.
Judicial review
  • Judicial review - is within the power of courts to strike down laws that violate an abiding, fundamental principle of law.
  • Article VI - supremacy clause - constitution is supreme law of the land
  • Article III: judges will interpret the conformity of laws to the supreme law of the land
  • The power of judicial review has been used by this court regularly and frequently over the time of its existence of more than 200 years.

  • EX
    • in 1954 struck down the racial segregation of public schools.
    • In 1967 it struck down a law in Virginia that barred people from marrying a person of the other race.
    • In 1971 it ruled that the government could not prevent the publication by newspapers of the Pentagon Papers.
    • In 1971, in a case from Idaho, it ruled for the first time in history that the doctrine of legal equality under the Constitution protects women from discrimination based upon their sex.
    • the principle that the Constitution provides full equality for gay and lesbian people to marry.
Other
  • In 1995 Supreme Court said that states cannot add to the qualifications for getting elected to the house.
  • Decision 5-to-4.
  • Majority used series of arguments the relationship between the national government and the people directly, the design of the Constitution in seeking to make members of the House the choice of the people, the text of the actual qualifications, and the limited capacity of the states to dictate the nature of the House.
  • Dissenters said the Constitution is silent on the matter, so the states were not forbidden to pursue a change they thought was a proper reform measure.
  • In another time, with a different set of Justices, the result might have come out differently


Professor: Lyle Denniston
University of Baltimore 

1 comment:

Week 11 Post 3 TED Talk Reviews

     I am surprised that there is so little democracy in the election process. I am also intrigued by how long the American brand of constit...