Tuesday, May 21, 2019

Week 7 Post 2 Bush v. Gore


          In 2000, one of Americas most political events took place, a presidential election.[1] The election, between George W. Bush and Al Gore came down to one state, Florida. Florida was won by Bush, but by a margin of 1784 votes, less than one-half of 1%. By Florida law this required a manual recount, which shrunk the margin to 327 votes. Under state law a candidate may request a manual recount under these circumstances, which Gore did in 4 counties that were traditionally democratic leaning. However, time and politics caused the Florida Secretary of State Katherine Harris to declare Bush the winner of the election in Florida. Gores campaign than obtained an order from the Florida Supreme Court for a statewide manual recount. The next day the US Supreme Court ordered a stay of the recount. Many people filed various Amicus Curiae. Writing for a five-justice majority, Scalia argued that the votes that were ordered to be counted were not legally cast, and thus a recount could cause irreparable harm to Bush and the legitimacy of the democratic process. The dissenters however, felt that not ordering a recount would undermine the legitimacy of the democratic process and that the court should be careful taking actions that could determine the result of an election which lay outside of there power. However, 7 justices agreed that a manual statewide recount would violate the Equal Protection Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment, as standards for manual recounts varied across counties, such that individual voters could not be sure that their participation in the democratic process would be given proper weight. Many legal scholars and political figures felt that the Court had gone too far in addressing something outside its power under the political question doctrine, while others felt that it had not gone far enough in pointing out the need for nationwide electoral reform.

          The constitution is an oversight for politics and the supreme court interprets the constitution. Bush v. Gore is an example on how the Supreme Court is an oversight for politics, more specifically, when parts of the constitution conflict. Bush v. Gore is based on the precedence for presidential elections from the constitution, but also the fourteenth amendment. Thus, Bush v. Gore became a question on the reach of the authority of the court verses the duty it must interpret the constitution. In both instances, the court interacts with politics, whether they stayed to vote or not, the Court was involved in the outcome of the 2000 election. However, this forced interaction with politics is only against the principles of the supreme court if the ultimate decision comes out of personal biases. The end result is that the supreme court can interact with politics without being political, but the line can be easily crossed. 



[1] If I need to explain presidential elections, I’m leaving

1 comment:

  1. No need to explain elections. :) Can you make sure that you go back a capitalize the Supreme Court?

    ReplyDelete

Week 11 Post 3 TED Talk Reviews

     I am surprised that there is so little democracy in the election process. I am also intrigued by how long the American brand of constit...