Decisions are not supposed to depend on which team or litigant the judge wants to prevail, not supposed to depend on whether the judge agrees with the rule or the law
Less important for Roberts that judges act like umpires than judges be thought to act like them
Wanted to assuage fears that he would manipulate the law to serve his favored policy ends – claimed to have no agenda and only call “balls and strikes”
Judges “make” the law by construing open-ended provisions of the Constitution and by interpreting statutes was beside the point
The important consideration was that judges (and umpires) who are believed to be doing no more than applying the law would escape some of the controversy and criticism that they might receive if the full scope of their discretion were realized.
Division between the reality and the appearance of judging is at the heart of Williams-Yulee v. Florida Bar 2015
Court upheld a prohibition on the personal solicitation of funds by judicial candidates
Court limited a prior case, Republican Party of Minnesota v. White, struck down a prohibition on judicial candidates’ announcement of their views on disputed legal or political issues
White – realistic – viewing judges as human beings who make policy
Voters in judicial elections should be able to base their votes on differences between judicial candidates that affect the way those candidates are likely to decide cases
Williams-Yulee – not reality but appearance that is paramount
Court downplays the policy making role of judges and accepts that states have a compelling interest in encouraging the public to believe in an idealized image of the judiciary because that is the image most likely to presence public confidence in and public willingness to follow, the courts
Williams-Yulee
In 2009, Lanell Williams-Yulee ran for county judge in Florida. Wrote and signed a letter announcing her candidacy and requesting campaign contributions, then mailed the letter to supporters and posted it on her campaign’s website
Florida Bar disciplined her for violating Florida’s Code of Judicial conduct, prohibits candidates from personally soliciting campaign funds
Ban on personal solicitation did very little to prevent favoritism , candidates knew who was giving money to their campaign, contributors could respond to committees solicitations knowing that the candidates would be thankful for their support, potential contributors could also fear that their failure to offer support could lead to retaliation
Florida thought it looked bad for judges to be asking for money – committees fundraising was believed to do less to tarnish the above the fray image of the judiciary
Activity protected by first amendment
Allows government to limit the electoral speech of candidates seeking support from constituents in order to influence the public to have a more positive image of the government
the principle that speech can be limited to prop up an idealistic and unrealistic image of government is a dangerous one
some limits on electoral speech are necessary to serve compelling ends, such as protecting access to the polls the government should not be able to limit speech to make sure that the public thinks well of the government
unlike Williams-Yulee, which focused on appearances, White focused on whether impartiality would be threatened by the prohibited speech
Court first tried to determine which of three possible kinds of “impartiality” the state might have wanted to promote: lack of favoritism between parties, lack of preconceived legal views, and open mindedness
Ultimately, the Court found each kind of impartiality insufficient to justify the Minnesota’s speech restriction
Court considered the actuality and appearance of impartiality together
held that the speech restriction was not narrowly tailored to promote either the actuality or appearance of a judiciary that was free from party bias
the White Court took seriously the requirement that states not suppress any more speech than necessary
judges are not—and should not be—” impartial” in the sense of lacking all preconceptions on legal issues
one of the most important functions of the First Amendment: ensuring that limits on speech do not privilege one set of speakers or one set of viewpoints—such as the viewpoint that judges should enjoy public confidence in their integrity
the public dislikes and distrusts politicians – judges /= politicians
IMAGE IS EVERYTHING: POLITICS, UMPIRING, AND
THE JUDICIAL MYTH
MICHAEL R. DIMINO, SR.
Great Notes!
ReplyDelete