Marriage cases
Obergefell v. Hodges
Baker v. Nelson
DOMA
Before – same-sex marriage already established by law, court ruling, or voter initiative in 36 states, the District of Columbia, and Guam.
After – open marriage legally in remaining 14 states
consolidation of 6 lower court cases repesenting 16 same sex couples 4 states
Give new legal protection for those who got married under court rulings that could not be considered truly final until the Supreme Court had decided the constitutional question
Nullified bans on same-sex marriage and bans on official recognition of such marriages performed outside a state – violate 14th amendment’s guarantees of due process and equal protection
Debaters of topic have 1st amendment free speech rights
Debates might focus on claims that same-sex marriage will intrude on the religious rights of those whose faith tells them that the institution should be open only for opposite-sex couples
Under Supreme Court rules no formal order to put into effect a decision
Reverse rulings of lower courts in 4 states
Other states must be resolved by federal appeals courts in 1st 5th 8th circuits
5 for 4 dissent
Dissenting opinion – the court majority for reviving a judicial tradition of writing a judge’s own social perspectives into the Constitution
Loving v. Virginia 1967
Restrictions on miscegenation existed as early as the colonial era
Of 50 us states all but 9 has had a law against the practice at some point
Miscegenation: any marriage or interbreeding among different races
Pace v. Alabama 1883
US Supreme court ruled that an Alabama anti-miscegenation law was constitutional because it punished black and whites equally
Mildred Jeter and Richard Loving, mixed-race couple living in rural Virginia, crossed the Potomac River to marry in Washington, D.C. in violation of Virginia’s criminal ban on evasive interracial marriage. When they returned home, they were arrested. Initially accepting a suspended sentence on the condition that they leave the state of Virginia for 25 years, the Loving’s eventually contacted advocates in civil rights movement 2
1963 Mildred loving wrote a letter to US attorney general Robert F kennedy asking for assistance, kennedy referred lovings to the ACLU who agreed to take the case
During oral arguments before the supreme court defended the constitutionality of states anti-miscegenation law and compared it to similar regulations against incest and polygamy
During one exchange, Hirschkop stated that Virginia’s interracial marriage law and others like it were rooted in racism and white supremacy. “These are not health and welfare laws,” he argued. “These are slavery laws, pure and simple.”
In Loving, the Supreme Court invalidated Virginia’s ban on interracial marriage on grounds that it violated the equal protection clause and the due process clause of the Constitution (14)
Unanimous Under our Constitution, the freedom to marry, or not marry, a person of another race resides with the individual, and cannot be infringed by the state, - warren
Struck down interracial marriage laws in 16 states
Marked beginning of federal court intervention into state marriage law
https://www.loc.gov/item/usrep388001/
Before
Tail end of miscegenation bans
3
Between 1913 and 1948, 30 out of the then 48 states enforced anti-miscegenation laws
Only Connecticut, New Hampshire, New York, New Jersey, Vermont, Wisconsin, Minnesota, Alaska, Hawaii, and the District of Columbia never enacted them.
Tuesday, May 21, 2019
Week 8 Post 2 Marriage Cases
Miscegenation, any marriage or interbreeding among different races. In 1883, in Pace v. Alabama, the US Supreme Court ruled that an Alabama anti-miscegenation law was constitutional because it punished black and whites equally. In 1958, Mildred Jeter and Richard Loving, a mixed-race couple living in rural Virginia, crossed the Potomac River to marry in Washington D.C. in violation of Virginia’s criminal ban on evasive interracial marriage. When the returned home they were arrested. The Loving’s accepted a suspended sentence on the condition that they leave the state of Virginia for 25 years. In 1963 Mildred Loving wrote a letter to US attorney general Robert F. Kennedy asking for assistance, and Kennedy referred the Loving’s to the ACLU, who agreed to take the case. During one exchange during the oral arguments one of the lawyers stated that Virginia’s interracial marriage law and others like it were rooted in racism and white supremacy. The Supreme Court invalidated Virginia’s ban on interracial marriage on the grounds that it violated the 14th amendment. This struck down interracial marriage laws in 16 states. This case marked the beginning of federal court intervention into state marriage law.
In 1972 the Supreme Court upheld a Minnesota Supreme Court ruling, Baker v. Nelson, that said that the constitution does not protect a fundamental right for same-sex couples to get married. On Jan 16, 2015, the Supreme Court consolidated 4 cases concerning same-sex marriage cases challenging state laws that prohibited same-sex marriage and agreed to review the case. This would later become known as Obergefell v. Hodges. The ruling resulted in new legal protection for those who got married under court rulings that could not be considered truly final until the Supreme Court had decided the constitutional question. It also nullified bans on same-sex marriage and bans on official recognition of such marriages performed outside a state. The dissenting opinion for the case was concerned with the court majority for reviving a judicial tradition of writing a judge’s own social perspectives into the Constitution.
Marriage between anyone other than two white people of opposite genders has always been controversial. Going from slave masters desire to control slave lives, to anti-miscegenation laws during and after reconstruction, to the homophobia concerning marriage between two people of the same sex, marriage is a controversial issue in America. Pace v. Alabama, Loving v. Virginia, Baker v. Nelson, and Obergefell v. Hodges all deal with the balance between upholding constitution rights and prejudice. While both cases are clear examples of injustices against the fourteenth amendment, the justice’s decisions were influenced by the ideas of the time. If the supreme court was supposed to be an organization above the petty, fluctuating, opinions of the people, then there should never be needed to change precedence. However, the judges are not above internal discrimination and politics intersect with the court at this point between the intersection of ideas and duty.
Week 7 Post 2 Bush v. Gore
In 2000, one of Americas most political events took place, a
presidential election.[1]
The election, between George W. Bush and Al Gore came down to one state, Florida.
Florida was won by Bush, but by a margin of 1784 votes, less than one-half of
1%. By Florida law this required a manual recount, which shrunk the margin to
327 votes. Under state law a candidate may request a manual recount under these
circumstances, which Gore did in 4 counties that were traditionally democratic
leaning. However, time and politics caused the Florida Secretary of State
Katherine Harris to declare Bush the winner of the election in Florida. Gores
campaign than obtained an order from the Florida Supreme Court for a statewide
manual recount. The next day the US Supreme Court ordered a stay of the
recount. Many people filed various Amicus Curiae. Writing for a five-justice
majority, Scalia argued that the votes that were ordered to be counted were not
legally cast, and thus a recount could cause irreparable harm to Bush and the
legitimacy of the democratic process. The dissenters however, felt that not ordering
a recount would undermine the legitimacy of the democratic process and that the
court should be careful taking actions that could determine the result of an election
which lay outside of there power. However, 7 justices agreed that a manual statewide
recount would violate the Equal Protection Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment,
as standards for manual recounts varied across counties, such that individual
voters could not be sure that their participation in the democratic process
would be given proper weight. Many legal scholars and political figures felt
that the Court had gone too far in addressing something outside its power under
the political question doctrine, while others felt that it had not gone far enough
in pointing out the need for nationwide electoral reform.
The constitution is an oversight for politics and the
supreme court interprets the constitution. Bush v. Gore is an example on how
the Supreme Court is an oversight for politics, more specifically, when parts
of the constitution conflict. Bush v. Gore is based on the precedence for presidential
elections from the constitution, but also the fourteenth amendment. Thus, Bush
v. Gore became a question on the reach of the authority of the court verses the
duty it must interpret the constitution. In both instances, the court interacts
with politics, whether they stayed to vote or not, the Court was involved in
the outcome of the 2000 election. However, this forced interaction with
politics is only against the principles of the supreme court if the ultimate decision
comes out of personal biases. The end result is that the supreme court can
interact with politics without being political, but the line can be easily crossed.
Saturday, May 18, 2019
Week 7 Post 1 Bush v Gore
Bush v. Palm Beach County Canvasing Board
Al gore challenged decision of Harris to certify Bush as winner on Nov 12, deadline stablished by Florida statue
Gore asserted Harris had disregarded manual recount results in 4 Florida districts
Florida Supreme court respond by holding that harris wait until nov 26 to certify winner and must include manual recount results
Did post-election court decisions in Florida violate due process clause or 3 U.S.C 5?
Did Florida supreme court violate article 2 of US Constitution, absolute power in federal election matters on state legislatures, when allegedly changed the manner in which Florida’s electoral votes were chosen
The Court unanimously held that there was "considerable uncertainty" as to the reasons for the Florida Supreme Court's decision.
Declined to review the questions presented
Background:
Presidential election 2000
Bush won Florida by 1784 votes, less than one-half of 1 %, Florida law requires automatic machine recount
After margin shrink to 327 votes, understate law a candidate may request a manual recount
Gore does in 4 counties traditionally democratic leaning
Concerned about meaning 7 day deadline, do not make it
Florida Secretary of State Katherine Harris required counties seeking to make a late filing to submit a written explanation for why it was necessary. She found that none of the explanations met the criteria that she had imposed on herself for determining whether late filings would be admitted. Harris thus certified Bush the winner of the election in Florida after receiving overseas absentee ballots.
Gore’s campaign obtains order from Florida Supreme Court for a statewide manual recount
On next day US supreme court order a stay of the recount
Writing for 5 Justice majority, Antonin Scalia argued that the votes that were ordered to be counted were not legally cast, and thus a recount could cause irreparable harm to Bush and the legitimacy of the democratic process.
Dissenters felt that not ordering a recount would undermine the legitimacy of the democratic process and court should be careful about taking actions that could determine the result of an election, which lay outside power
7 justices - a manual statewide recount would violate the Equal Protection Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment
standards for manual recounts varied arbitrarily across counties and even precincts, so individual voters could not be sure that their participation in the democratic process would be given the proper weight
many legal scholars and political figures felt that the Court had gone too far in addressing something outside its power under the political question doctrine, while others felt that it had not gone far enough in pointing out the need for nationwide electoral reform.
George W. Bush vs Albert Gore Jr
Petition for writ of certiorari filed – dec 9 2000
Petition granted
Briefs of the parties not to exceed 50 pages are to be filled with clerk on or before 4 pm dec 10 2000
Oral argument dec 11 2000 at 11 am – 90 min
Amicus curiae
Florida House of Representatives and Florida Senate
Michael F. Wasserman
William H. Haynes, et al.
Alabama
Mary Ann Smania
National Bar Association
Robert Harris, Steven Medina, and other Florida Voters
Brennan Center for Justice at NYU School of Law
Robet A. Butterworth, Attorney General of Florida
https://www.supremecourt.gov/Search.aspx?FileName=/docketfiles/00-949.htm
https://supreme.justia.com/cases/federal/us/531/98/
Al gore challenged decision of Harris to certify Bush as winner on Nov 12, deadline stablished by Florida statue
Gore asserted Harris had disregarded manual recount results in 4 Florida districts
Florida Supreme court respond by holding that harris wait until nov 26 to certify winner and must include manual recount results
Did post-election court decisions in Florida violate due process clause or 3 U.S.C 5?
Did Florida supreme court violate article 2 of US Constitution, absolute power in federal election matters on state legislatures, when allegedly changed the manner in which Florida’s electoral votes were chosen
The Court unanimously held that there was "considerable uncertainty" as to the reasons for the Florida Supreme Court's decision.
Declined to review the questions presented
Background:
Presidential election 2000
Bush won Florida by 1784 votes, less than one-half of 1 %, Florida law requires automatic machine recount
After margin shrink to 327 votes, understate law a candidate may request a manual recount
Gore does in 4 counties traditionally democratic leaning
Concerned about meaning 7 day deadline, do not make it
Florida Secretary of State Katherine Harris required counties seeking to make a late filing to submit a written explanation for why it was necessary. She found that none of the explanations met the criteria that she had imposed on herself for determining whether late filings would be admitted. Harris thus certified Bush the winner of the election in Florida after receiving overseas absentee ballots.
Gore’s campaign obtains order from Florida Supreme Court for a statewide manual recount
On next day US supreme court order a stay of the recount
Writing for 5 Justice majority, Antonin Scalia argued that the votes that were ordered to be counted were not legally cast, and thus a recount could cause irreparable harm to Bush and the legitimacy of the democratic process.
Dissenters felt that not ordering a recount would undermine the legitimacy of the democratic process and court should be careful about taking actions that could determine the result of an election, which lay outside power
7 justices - a manual statewide recount would violate the Equal Protection Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment
standards for manual recounts varied arbitrarily across counties and even precincts, so individual voters could not be sure that their participation in the democratic process would be given the proper weight
many legal scholars and political figures felt that the Court had gone too far in addressing something outside its power under the political question doctrine, while others felt that it had not gone far enough in pointing out the need for nationwide electoral reform.
George W. Bush vs Albert Gore Jr
Petition for writ of certiorari filed – dec 9 2000
Petition granted
Briefs of the parties not to exceed 50 pages are to be filled with clerk on or before 4 pm dec 10 2000
Oral argument dec 11 2000 at 11 am – 90 min
Amicus curiae
Florida House of Representatives and Florida Senate
Michael F. Wasserman
William H. Haynes, et al.
Alabama
Mary Ann Smania
National Bar Association
Robert Harris, Steven Medina, and other Florida Voters
Brennan Center for Justice at NYU School of Law
Robet A. Butterworth, Attorney General of Florida
https://www.supremecourt.gov/Search.aspx?FileName=/docketfiles/00-949.htm
https://supreme.justia.com/cases/federal/us/531/98/
Tuesday, April 9, 2019
Week 6 Post 3 Supreme Court Appointments
This week’s learning has given me many interesting and surprising facts that I did not know. I was intrigued about how low the confirmation rate is for Judicial appointment (57 failed out of 162). I was also curious about the fact that in order to try and predict who comes back to the court people look at who has hired clerks for the next term. I also have found the careers of John Marshall, John Jay, and John Rutledge to be interesting.
This week some questions I have are how often does the Senate take the ABA ratings into consideration? I would also like to know how many senators change their opinions based on what is reveled in meetings with the candidate. This week I only learned about what the current conformation process looks like and I would like to know more about what confirmation processes have looked like in the past.
This week some questions I have are how often does the Senate take the ABA ratings into consideration? I would also like to know how many senators change their opinions based on what is reveled in meetings with the candidate. This week I only learned about what the current conformation process looks like and I would like to know more about what confirmation processes have looked like in the past.
Week 6 Post 2 Supreme Court Appointment
No Justices stay on the Supreme Court for forever. Eventually Justices leave the court, by death or by retirement. When a this happens, a vacancy is created on the Supreme Court. These vacancies start the Supreme Court nominations process. The first step in the process is the current President chooses a nominee. This choice is not limited by the Constitution and can be anyone from any way of life. However, as the head of a political part, the chief executive seldom, if ever, chooses someone other than one of the party’s own. The president must also consider what happens in the next stage of the process, Senate confirmation, when choosing a candidate. Once a president has a candidate in mind, they have a meeting with the Senate leadership: the Senate majority leader, the minority leader, and the chairman and ranking member on the Judiciary Committee. Then the nominee will come up for courtesy visits to the Senate and meets with the Senate leadership. Following that they will attempt meetings with each senator. The nominee then comes before the Senate Judiciary Committee for a hearing, and the Committee will vote and report the nomination to the Senate. The Senate will then vote to confirm or deny the candidate. However, in 1949 the Senate allowed for unlimited debate on nominations made by the president to any appointed position in the government, a 60-vote majority is needed for a Supreme Court nomination debate to end and for voting to commence.
The Supreme Court nomination process is one of the largest ways the Supreme Court interacts with politics. One of the greatest interactions the process had with American politics was the appointment of Justice of the Supreme Court Brandeis. Brandeis was nominated by Wilson in 1916 after the death of Supreme Court Justice Joseph R. Lamar. Brandeis was a Jewish Boston lawyer, who pushed a very progressive agenda. His appointment caused a 4-month long senate confirmation battle. Several influential people were against the appointment due to Antisemitism. Brandeis was one of the country’s most celebrated progressive reformers and the only thing truly preventing his appointment was the politics of the time.
The Supreme Court nomination process is one of the largest ways the Supreme Court interacts with politics. One of the greatest interactions the process had with American politics was the appointment of Justice of the Supreme Court Brandeis. Brandeis was nominated by Wilson in 1916 after the death of Supreme Court Justice Joseph R. Lamar. Brandeis was a Jewish Boston lawyer, who pushed a very progressive agenda. His appointment caused a 4-month long senate confirmation battle. Several influential people were against the appointment due to Antisemitism. Brandeis was one of the country’s most celebrated progressive reformers and the only thing truly preventing his appointment was the politics of the time.
Friday, April 5, 2019
Week 6 Post 1 Supreme Court Appointment
- Fourth Chief Justice
- Continental Army volunteer
- Served two terms in the Virginia house of delegates
- Defended the Constitution in the state’s ratifying convention
- US House of Representatives
- John Adams's Secretary of State
Someone leaves the supreme Court
- Dying or retiring – is there going to be a vacancy
- Courtesy is to notify the president before you announce it publicly
- When the court gets near the end of a term there is always speculations about who’s going to leave or not leave
- Look at what justices have hired clerks for the next term
- Good indication that they plan to come back
- The constitution does not limit the choice – can be anybody
- Earl Warren – Governor of California
- Hugo Black – senator from Alabama
- Elena Kagan – Solicitor General, Harvard Law School Dean
- Sandra Day O’Connor – Arizona State legislature, intermediate appellate judge in Arizona
- Reflects calculations about how to maximize the political benefit for the president
- As the head of a political party, the chief executive can seldom, if ever, choose someone other than one of the party’s own
- Must consider the potential for Senate approval or rejection (162 nominations, 57 failed in Senate)
- seek advice from the Senate
- President will seek a meeting with the Senate leadership-
- Senate majority leader, minority leader, chairman and ranking member on the Judiciary Committee
- The nominee will come up for courtesy visits in the Senate and will meet with the Senate leadership (see above), and all the committee members
- Try to meet with each senator
- Don’t get to all 100, but 70-80 of them
- All closed-door meetings
- Senators ask the nominee about cases
- The nominee comes before the Senate Judiciary Committee for a hearing
- The Committee will vote and the full senate will report the nomination to the Committee
- Filibuster/nuclear opinion
- 1949 – Senate rules allow unlimited debate on nominations made by the president to any appointed position in the government, previously only allowed on actual legislation
- 4 times between 1968 and 2006
- On three occasions, supporters were able to gather enough votes to shut off debate and nominations were then approved
- One time (1968) not enough votes to end debate on nomination of Justice Abe Fortas to become Chief Justice, and President Lyndon Johnson withdrew nomination
- On Nov 21, 2013, senate voted to change rules so that a filibuster on any lower-court nomination or any nominee for an Executive Branch position could be ended with the vote of a simple majority of the Senate
- 60 vote majority on a Supreme Court nomination remained intact
- Acts in full view of the public
- Has a standing committee that’s removed from its House of Delegates, not part of the advocacy work that the ABA does.
- Evaluates judicial temperament and judicial ability
- Rate nominees as highly qualified, qualified, or unqualified
- Wilson nominated in 1916
- 59 years of age
- Boston lawyer
- First Jewish justice
- Aggressive practicing lawyer – pushing progressive agenda
- 4-month long senate confirmation battle
- One of the country’s most celebrated progressive reformers
- Antisemitic opposition prevented Wilson from appointing Brandeis as the country’s first Jewish Attorney General in 1913
- A brief that tries to educate a court about the real-world impact of the decisions
- Factual brief
- Lots of social science and statistics
- Not been a judge, practicing lawyer in Dallas
- Withdrawn because conservatives pressured the Bush White House to withdraw her
- Felt she was not reliable
- The press that covers the Supreme Court tends to contribute to the idea that the Court is political by referring to the justices as Rep. justices or Dem. Justices
- Inviting readers to conclude that the only reason they voted that way was because of their Republican political allegiance
Sarah S. Herman: Legislative Attorney
March 31, 2016
- Are Nine Justices Required?
- No, constitution says nothing about a number
- 6 justices needed for a quorum
- If there is not a quorum, might announce that the Court will not meet until a quorum is restored
- Is the President Required to Appoint a New Justice?
- Constitution wording is shall – generally imposes a mandatory obligation
- Supreme Court precedent regarding vacancies in other positions subject to presidential appointment suggests that the President has significant discretion as to when a vacancy “shall” be filled.
- Is the Senate Required to Act Once the President Submits a Nomination?
- Senate gives advice and consent
- In the past – various means, committee hearings to a vote on the Senate floor
- Some view the Senate’s role to give advice as an active one, in which failing to consider a nominee at all would violate its constitutional obligations
- others assert that the Senate has no constitutional obligation to act once the President nominates a new Justice. See no shall
- Can the President Make a Recess Appointment for a Supreme Court Justice?
- Inconclusive, Recess Appointment Clause ish
- Could a Nominee Who Is Rejected, or Not Subject to Senate Action, Be Re-nominated?
- Yes, nothing in the Constitution or in any federal law prohibits the President from re-nominating a Supreme Court nominee who was rejected or never voted on during the Senate’s term
- When May the Supreme Court Rehear Cases that Have Already Been Argued?
- For cases already decided on the merits, a majority of the Court must grant the petition for rehearing, which would be considered only at the request of one of the Justices who concurred in the Court’s judgment on the merits.
- the Court typically will order cases to be reheard if the Justices conclude that they cannot resolve the case before the Court’s summer recess
- political access and alignments are often very important in the choice of a Justice
- a career joining politics to law is a good foundation for a career on the Court
- the skills learned in political maneuvering are not entirely set aside in the process of judging
- a system of mutual dependence, one in which neither could absolutely control the process but in which the differing outlooks of the two would be at work -- the President oriented toward national political perspectives and the Senate attuned to the state-by-state perspectives that may come more directly from the people.
- “Whenever a particular statute contravenes the Constitution, it will be the duty of the judicial tribunals to adhere to the latter and disregard the former,” Hamilton said in The Federalist No. 78.
- Every justice has some political roots, and a patron
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
Week 11 Post 3 TED Talk Reviews
I am surprised that there is so little democracy in the election process. I am also intrigued by how long the American brand of constit...
-
Judicial independence is essential to the very foundation of our democratic society. However, it might not be a good thing. Justice ...
-
My reaction to learning about the articles of Confederacy was shock that they lasted as long as they did, and astonishment at how differen...
-
The first attempt the colonies made at governing themselves was the article of confederation. They had one branch of government, congress...