When creating the judicial branch of the government the founders drew on many different people and experiences. Two people that had a major influence on them were Sir Edward Coke and Baron de Montesquieu. Sir Edward Coke was an English lawyer, judge, and scholar. His main legacy is the idea of the independence of the judiciary and the principle that judges many overturn statues which are contrary to the fundamental rights. Baron de Montesquieu was a French political theorist who believed that all men given power will abuse it and therefore came up with the bases of the checks and balances that the writers of the constitution used to form the tree branches of government. However, while Montesquieu was concerned with despots the founders were more concerned with the public itself. When writing the constitution, the founders drew from two main experiences, the judicial system under the British, and the absolute failure of the Articles of Confederation. Under the British the colonies had their own courts; however, these courts were overseen by the Judicial Committer of the Privy Council. One thing that angered many colonists during this time was the British governments refusal to allow for life-tenured judges. This became such a point of controversy between the two groups that it was listed as a grievance on the Declaration of Independence. However, once the colonists gained their freedom, the new government, the Articles of Confederation, were weakened by the absence of a central judicial authority, as state courts, the highest level of court, favored their own states laws when conflicts arose.
Once the constitution was written and the new government was formed most of the judicial system was laid out in Article III. Section 1 of this article highlights the three important facts of the supreme court directly outlines in the constitution: that it was a single court at the apex of the federal judiciary, the justices would serve for life providing good behavior as they were not exempted from the impeachment process, and an assured salary that congress did not have control over. These factors served to help one main aspect of the court, that it was and would always be independent of the other branches of governments, such that the decisions it made would not be affected by possible retaliation. From there the Judiciary act of 1789 created a six-member supreme court plus layers of lower appeal and trail courts in the federal system. One of the main controversies over this new court was the fact that it enhanced the power of the national government at the expense of the states. However as federal authority would be seriously compromised if state courts had the final word on federal constitutional issues, as seen under the Articles of Confederation, this was necessary evil. The Supreme Court was more likely than the state courts to uphold federal power and see to it that the laws and treaties of the United States were uniformly enforced.
When the constitution was first penned it was widely assumed in early American legal circles that the new courts would follow the practice of English courts in giving legal advice outside the context of specific lawsuits. However, after an incident were George Washington asked for advice on the neutrality stance and the court could not comply it soon became clear that the court was not an executive appendage. This response written by at that time Chief justice John Jay was sighted in later supreme court decisions to strike down federal law commands for federal courts to decide cases that did not involve genuine legal controversy. However, one power that few predicted was judicial review. The Supreme Courts use of judicial review, the power of courts to strike down laws that violate an abiding, fundamental principle of law, came from the 1803 court case Marbury v. Madison. This power has been used several times over the 200 years of the court’s existence on some of the most controversial and remembered decisions.
The election of 1800 was a landmark election, representing the peaceful passing of power from the Federalists to the Democratic-Republicans. However, out of this passing of power came on of the first interactions between the supreme court, Marbury v. Madison. Marbury v. Madison was the first time in the supreme courts history that they effected american politics directly. By taking a stance they established that they were a force to be reckoned with and that they could have at least some influence over the other branches in this way. While the decision might not have effected American politics in the long run, the fact that they could would be important in the future.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
Week 11 Post 3 TED Talk Reviews
I am surprised that there is so little democracy in the election process. I am also intrigued by how long the American brand of constit...
-
Judicial independence is essential to the very foundation of our democratic society. However, it might not be a good thing. Justice ...
-
My reaction to learning about the articles of Confederacy was shock that they lasted as long as they did, and astonishment at how differen...
-
The first attempt the colonies made at governing themselves was the article of confederation. They had one branch of government, congress...
Well written and informative. Do you think there are any drawbacks to life tenures of Supreme Court Justices?
ReplyDeleteI think that one drawback to life tenures on the Supreme Court is that the people and there opinions circulate out causing the same people to make similar decisions.
ReplyDelete