- If government is meant to serve the people why is there a system in which one of the parts is an institution not chosen by the people, has members who serve for life and has not duty to account to the people directly on how it uses its power
- Americans have a higher level of trust in the judicial branch than either of the others
- Only 5 amendment have specially overturned rulings by the court
- the 13th, abolishing slavery
- the 14th, guaranteeing legal equality to freed slaves
- the 19th, giving women the right to vote
- the 24th, banning poll taxes
- and the 26th, giving 18, 19 and 20-year-olds the right to vote.
- Power checks
- Justices do not run for election
- Never answer to the votes in any direct sense
- Constitution amendment
- Extremely difficult to get the consensus needed
- Impeachment
- Impeachment only used once – Samuel chase of Maryland – acquitted
- Legislative action
- Congress can pass laws to reduce the jurisdiction of the Supreme court to hear appeals from the lower courts
- Congress must approve the spending of any money by the supreme court
- Once a year at lease on justice must
testify before congressional committees to explain and justify the court budget
- lawmakers frequently use those appearances to vent some of their discontent with the Court’s rulings
- congress selfdoms modify the courts budget
- Judge nomination
- Judges are appointed by the president and confirmed by the Senate – House has no role
- the arrival of each new Justice always has a significant impact on how the Court performs its functions
- dynamic of decision-making does change
- the doctrine of the separation of powers requires the judiciary to be independent of the elected branches of government
- following the rule of law requires judicial independence
- in order for judges to tread in the service of justice, they must be impartial and fair in deciding cases.
- Neither impartiality nor fairness is possible if the judiciary is controlled by another branch.
- judicial independence"? For starters, it is fair, impartial, and honest adjudication motivated by a commitment to justice and the expression of justice in law
- the current way to get on the court is to work first in the executive branch for a justice department
- Ex: Justice Gorsuch, Thomas, Alito, Roberts, Kagan
- Service in the executive branch tends to make you more ideologically oriented in a partisan sense -working for a president’s administration had distinct policy goals that everyone works for
- Bring that to the court with you
- The court has taken over as the guardian of the representative democracy
- Detached judgement - Ingredients of choice are always present
- Marbury v Madison – political decision about the power of the court
- Bush v. Gore, - relied on the Fourteenth Amendment’s equality of rights among voters to settle that year’s presidential election
- Which branch of the government should be determining the rules of campaign finance
- Supreme court – know less about politics that any of the other branches
- Congress – pass laws that will protect their own reelection
- At its core it is a constitutional question – supreme court or an amendment
- Because money talks, money is a form of expression protected fully and gradly by the first amendment
- Do people with experience with politics bring something to the court
- Yes –
- Sandra day O’Connor – instincts as a political figure – very important in given her the role of the swing justice
- Lewis Powell – been in local government and board of schools- also swing justice
- Tony Kennedy – experience of being a lobbyist before the California legislature so he knew political method and political progress – brings seasoned political perspective
University of Baltimore
Supreme court – know less about politics that any of the other branches (?)
ReplyDeleteWhat it means is that the other branches deal with more politics on a regular basis and therefore might be better equipped.
ReplyDelete