Miscegenation, any marriage or interbreeding among different races. In 1883, in Pace v. Alabama, the US Supreme Court ruled that an Alabama anti-miscegenation law was constitutional because it punished black and whites equally. In 1958, Mildred Jeter and Richard Loving, a mixed-race couple living in rural Virginia, crossed the Potomac River to marry in Washington D.C. in violation of Virginia’s criminal ban on evasive interracial marriage. When the returned home they were arrested. The Loving’s accepted a suspended sentence on the condition that they leave the state of Virginia for 25 years. In 1963 Mildred Loving wrote a letter to US attorney general Robert F. Kennedy asking for assistance, and Kennedy referred the Loving’s to the ACLU, who agreed to take the case. During one exchange during the oral arguments one of the lawyers stated that Virginia’s interracial marriage law and others like it were rooted in racism and white supremacy. The Supreme Court invalidated Virginia’s ban on interracial marriage on the grounds that it violated the 14th amendment. This struck down interracial marriage laws in 16 states. This case marked the beginning of federal court intervention into state marriage law.
In 1972 the Supreme Court upheld a Minnesota Supreme Court ruling, Baker v. Nelson, that said that the constitution does not protect a fundamental right for same-sex couples to get married. On Jan 16, 2015, the Supreme Court consolidated 4 cases concerning same-sex marriage cases challenging state laws that prohibited same-sex marriage and agreed to review the case. This would later become known as Obergefell v. Hodges. The ruling resulted in new legal protection for those who got married under court rulings that could not be considered truly final until the Supreme Court had decided the constitutional question. It also nullified bans on same-sex marriage and bans on official recognition of such marriages performed outside a state. The dissenting opinion for the case was concerned with the court majority for reviving a judicial tradition of writing a judge’s own social perspectives into the Constitution.
Marriage between anyone other than two white people of opposite genders has always been controversial. Going from slave masters desire to control slave lives, to anti-miscegenation laws during and after reconstruction, to the homophobia concerning marriage between two people of the same sex, marriage is a controversial issue in America. Pace v. Alabama, Loving v. Virginia, Baker v. Nelson, and Obergefell v. Hodges all deal with the balance between upholding constitution rights and prejudice. While both cases are clear examples of injustices against the fourteenth amendment, the justice’s decisions were influenced by the ideas of the time. If the supreme court was supposed to be an organization above the petty, fluctuating, opinions of the people, then there should never be needed to change precedence. However, the judges are not above internal discrimination and politics intersect with the court at this point between the intersection of ideas and duty.
Remember to capitalize the Supreme Court. Do you think public sentiment could also play a role in these decisions?
ReplyDelete