Wednesday, May 29, 2019

Week 9 Post 2 Judicial Image


         Human beings are people and contain personal basis. A Supreme Court case, Republican Party of Minnesota v. White struck down a prohibition on judicial candidates’ announcement of their views on disputed legal or political issues. This case was a realistic decision that showed acknowledgement of judges as human beings who make policy. However, in a Supreme court case Williams-Yulee v. Florida Bar in 2015, the Supreme Court upheld a prohibition on the personal solicitation of funds by judicial candidates. In this case the court downplayed the policy making role of judges and accepts that states have a compelling interest in encouraging the public to believe in an idealized image of the judiciary became that is the image most likely to preserve public confidence and willingness to follow the courts. 
       Politics is made up of politicians. When the Supreme Court acknowledged that judges could be politicians, they showed the judges would interact with policies. This is the same as the recognizing that politics could impact the careers of judges. Additionally, the fact that they wanted to project an aura of being above politics implies that there is a need to clarify this and the they are not as separate as they wish to be. 


Sunday, May 26, 2019

Week 9 post 1 Judicial Image

IMAGE IS EVERYTHING: POLITICS, UMPIRING, AND THE JUDICIAL MYTH
Decisions are not supposed to depend on which team or litigant the judge wants to prevail, not supposed to depend on whether the judge agrees with the rule or the law
Less important for Roberts that judges act like umpires than judges be thought to act like them
Wanted to assuage fears that he would manipulate the law to serve his favored policy ends – claimed to have no agenda and only call “balls and strikes”
Judges “make” the law by construing open-ended provisions of the Constitution and by interpreting statutes was beside the point
The important consideration was that judges (and umpires) who are believed to be doing no more than applying the law would escape some of the controversy and criticism that they might receive if the full scope of their discretion were realized.
Division between the reality and the appearance of judging is at the heart of Williams-Yulee v. Florida Bar 2015
Court upheld a prohibition on the personal solicitation of funds by judicial candidates
Court limited a prior case, Republican Party of Minnesota v. White, struck down a prohibition on judicial candidates’ announcement of their views on disputed legal or political issues
White – realistic – viewing judges as human beings who make policy
Voters in judicial elections should be able to base their votes on differences between judicial candidates that affect the way those candidates are likely to decide cases
Williams-Yulee – not reality but appearance that is paramount
Court downplays the policy making role of judges and accepts that states have a compelling interest in encouraging the public to believe in an idealized image of the judiciary because that is the image most likely to presence public confidence in and public willingness to follow, the courts
Williams-Yulee
In 2009, Lanell Williams-Yulee ran for county judge in Florida. Wrote and signed a letter announcing her candidacy and requesting campaign contributions, then mailed the letter to supporters and posted it on her campaign’s website
Florida Bar disciplined her for violating Florida’s Code of Judicial conduct, prohibits candidates from personally soliciting campaign funds
Ban on personal solicitation did very little to prevent favoritism , candidates knew who was giving money to their campaign, contributors could respond to committees solicitations knowing that the candidates would be thankful for their support, potential contributors could also fear that their failure to offer support could lead to retaliation
Florida thought it looked bad for judges to be asking for money – committees fundraising was believed to do less to tarnish the above the fray image of the judiciary
Activity protected by first amendment
Allows government to limit the electoral speech of candidates seeking support from constituents in order to influence the public to have a more positive image of the government
the principle that speech can be limited to prop up an idealistic and unrealistic image of government is a dangerous one
some limits on electoral speech are necessary to serve compelling ends, such as protecting access to the polls the government should not be able to limit speech to make sure that the public thinks well of the government
unlike Williams-Yulee, which focused on appearances, White focused on whether impartiality would be threatened by the prohibited speech
Court first tried to determine which of three possible kinds of “impartiality” the state might have wanted to promote: lack of favoritism between parties, lack of preconceived legal views, and open mindedness
Ultimately, the Court found each kind of impartiality insufficient to justify the Minnesota’s speech restriction
Court considered the actuality and appearance of impartiality together
held that the speech restriction was not narrowly tailored to promote either the actuality or appearance of a judiciary that was free from party bias
the White Court took seriously the requirement that states not suppress any more speech than necessary
judges are not—and should not be—” impartial” in the sense of lacking all preconceptions on legal issues
one of the most important functions of the First Amendment: ensuring that limits on speech do not privilege one set of speakers or one set of viewpoints—such as the viewpoint that judges should enjoy public confidence in their integrity
the public dislikes and distrusts politicians – judges /= politicians


IMAGE IS EVERYTHING: POLITICS, UMPIRING, AND THE JUDICIAL MYTH MICHAEL R. DIMINO, SR. 

week 10 post 1 Judicial Independence


Unlike the political branches of government, the judiciary must be independent.
Acts fairly and impartially in consideration of what is just not what is popular
makes decisions after careful legal scrutiny firmly grounded on the rule of law, applied to the evidence in a particular case, without concerns for politics, the demands of special interest groups, or even the popular opinions of the majority
our judges are expected to stand strong despite the forces of popular opinion or political pushback in making their rulings free from pressure
judicial candidates are prohibited from sharing political views or how they might rule in certain cases
an independent judiciary is essential to the very foundation of our democratic society
Judicial independence empowers judges to check the other branches of government and resolve cases impartially and in accordance with law. Con because they are independent, judges can ignore law and pursue private agendas
We cannot decide how independent to make a judge until we agree on what a judge is supposed to do
Independent judges make some nonlegalistic decisions and each such decisions impose a high cost on society. Dependent judges make more nonlegalistic decisions, but each imposes a low cost on society
Society may prefer a dependent judge to adjudicate minority rights and that the determinacy of law can be irrelevant to the choice between an independent and a dependent judge
The debate rests on deep and contestable assumptions about the value of law
In 2009 the supreme court of Iowa unanimously held that same-sex couples have a right to marry under the state constitution, a year later, Iowans voted out three justices who joined that opinion, in the months leading up to the vote, out-of-state groups spent nearly one million dollars on political ads targeting the justices
Caperton v AT Massey coal co
An elected judge cast the decisive vote in a multimillion-dollar contract case in favor of the principal supporter of his election campaign after refusing to recuse himself
Supreme court held that the judge’s refusal to recuse violated the Constitution
Independence insulates judges from outside pressures and that empowers them to interpret law impartially, critical to the separation of powers and the rule of law, but little or no accountability
               Antithetical to democracy and might be dangerous as judges can ignore law and pursue personal agendas
Judicial independence signifies before turning to the debate it has sparked. Judicial independence is a state in which a judge cannot be penalized, and knows that he cannot be penalized, by other actors for his official decisions. He cannot receive a penalty such as a salary reduction, loss of his judgeship, imprisonment, a foregone benefit, or any other harm
The effects of public accountability are uncertain
Might cause judges to make decision that reflect the preferences of a representative citizen, regardless of whether the law requires different decisions
Might case judges to make decision that reflect the preferences of narrow interest groups that can influence elections and other judicial selection processes
Might also cause judges to remain utterly faithful to the law if that is what the public wants and to consider citizens preferences only in cases where the law is ambiguous
Much of the debate about judicial independence grows from disagreements about the effects of public accountability
A judge can be independent even if the executive does not enforce his decisions so long as failure to enforce does not harm the judge
A judge can be independent even if the legislature changes the law to override his decisions, so long as override does not harm the judge
Judicial independence matter most, if some judicial decisions are enforced and retained [2]







                                                                                 



[1] The Judicial Branch: Co-Equal and Independent, William J. Schifino Jr
[2] JUDICIAL INDEPENDENCE AND SOCIAL WELFARE Michael D. Gilbert

Tuesday, May 21, 2019

Week 8 Post 3 Marriage Cases

This week I was saddened by the human races capabilities for discrimination. However, I was also astounded by the resilience and lengths that people will go for love.  I was intrigued by the ways that the justices attempted to appease the people that disagreed with the decisions. However, I am also worried about how easily it is to change precedent.

I wonder about how many battles go on for rights on the state and local level that are ignored because we focus only on the Supreme Court. I also wonder about how many important cases have been forgotten by history because they no longer are applicable or interesting.

Week 8 Post 1 Marriage Cases

Marriage cases
Obergefell v. Hodges
Baker v. Nelson
DOMA
Before – same-sex marriage already established by law, court ruling, or voter initiative in 36 states, the District of Columbia, and Guam.
After – open marriage legally in remaining 14 states
consolidation of 6 lower court cases repesenting 16 same sex couples 4 states
Give new legal protection for those who got married under court rulings that could not be considered truly final until the Supreme Court had decided the constitutional question
Nullified bans on same-sex marriage and bans on official recognition of such marriages performed outside a state – violate 14th amendment’s guarantees of due process and equal protection
Debaters of topic have 1st amendment free speech rights
Debates might focus on claims that same-sex marriage will intrude on the religious rights of those whose faith tells them that the institution should be open only for opposite-sex couples
Under Supreme Court rules no formal order to put into effect a decision
 Reverse rulings of lower courts in 4 states
Other states must be resolved by federal appeals courts in 1st 5th 8th circuits
5 for 4 dissent
Dissenting opinion – the court majority for reviving a judicial tradition of writing a judge’s own social perspectives into the Constitution

Loving v. Virginia 1967
Restrictions on miscegenation existed as early as the colonial era
Of 50 us states all but 9 has had a law against the practice at some point
Miscegenation: any marriage or interbreeding among different races
Pace v. Alabama 1883
US Supreme court ruled that an Alabama anti-miscegenation law was constitutional because it punished black and whites equally

Mildred Jeter and Richard Loving, mixed-race couple living in rural Virginia, crossed the Potomac River to marry in Washington, D.C. in violation of Virginia’s criminal ban on evasive interracial marriage. When they returned home, they were arrested. Initially accepting a suspended sentence on the condition that they leave the state of Virginia for 25 years, the Loving’s eventually contacted advocates in civil rights movement 2
1963 Mildred loving wrote a letter to US attorney general Robert F kennedy asking for assistance, kennedy referred lovings to the ACLU who agreed to take the case
During oral arguments before the supreme court defended the constitutionality of states anti-miscegenation law and compared it to similar regulations against incest and polygamy
During one exchange, Hirschkop stated that Virginia’s interracial marriage law and others like it were rooted in racism and white supremacy. “These are not health and welfare laws,” he argued. “These are slavery laws, pure and simple.”
In Loving, the Supreme Court invalidated Virginia’s ban on interracial marriage on grounds that it violated the equal protection clause and the due process clause of the Constitution (14)
Unanimous Under our Constitution, the freedom to marry, or not marry, a person of another race resides with the individual, and cannot be infringed by the state, - warren
Struck down interracial marriage laws in 16 states
Marked beginning of federal court intervention into state marriage law

https://www.loc.gov/item/usrep388001/
Before
Tail end of miscegenation bans
 3
Between 1913 and 1948, 30 out of the then 48 states enforced anti-miscegenation laws
Only Connecticut, New Hampshire, New York, New Jersey, Vermont, Wisconsin, Minnesota, Alaska, Hawaii, and the District of Columbia never enacted them.


Week 8 Post 2 Marriage Cases


           Miscegenation, any marriage or interbreeding among different races. In 1883, in Pace v. Alabama, the US Supreme Court ruled that an Alabama anti-miscegenation law was constitutional because it punished black and whites equally. In 1958, Mildred Jeter and Richard Loving, a mixed-race couple living in rural Virginia, crossed the Potomac River to marry in Washington D.C. in violation of Virginia’s criminal ban on evasive interracial marriage. When the returned home they were arrested. The Loving’s accepted a suspended sentence on the condition that they leave the state of Virginia for 25 years. In 1963 Mildred Loving wrote a letter to US attorney general Robert F. Kennedy asking for assistance, and Kennedy referred the Loving’s to the ACLU, who agreed to take the case. During one exchange during the oral arguments one of the lawyers stated that Virginia’s interracial marriage law and others like it were rooted in racism and white supremacy. The Supreme Court invalidated Virginia’s ban on interracial marriage on the grounds that it violated the 14th amendment. This struck down interracial marriage laws in 16 states. This case marked the beginning of federal court intervention into state marriage law.

           In 1972 the Supreme Court upheld a Minnesota Supreme Court ruling, Baker v. Nelson, that said that the constitution does not protect a fundamental right for same-sex couples to get married. On Jan 16, 2015, the Supreme Court consolidated 4 cases concerning same-sex marriage cases challenging state laws that prohibited same-sex marriage and agreed to review the case. This would later become known as Obergefell v. Hodges. The ruling resulted in new legal protection for those who got married under court rulings that could not be considered truly final until the Supreme Court had decided the constitutional question. It also nullified bans on same-sex marriage and bans on official recognition of such marriages performed outside a state. The dissenting opinion for the case was concerned with the court majority for reviving a judicial tradition of writing a judge’s own social perspectives into the Constitution.

       Marriage between anyone other than two white people of opposite genders has always been controversial. Going from slave masters desire to control slave lives, to anti-miscegenation laws during and after reconstruction, to the homophobia concerning marriage between two people of the same sex, marriage is a controversial issue in America. Pace v. Alabama, Loving v. Virginia, Baker v. Nelson, and Obergefell v. Hodges all deal with the balance between upholding constitution rights and prejudice. While both cases are clear examples of injustices against the fourteenth amendment, the justice’s decisions were influenced by the ideas of the time. If the supreme court was supposed to be an organization above the petty, fluctuating, opinions of the people, then there should never be needed to change precedence. However, the judges are not above internal discrimination and politics intersect with the court at this point between the intersection of ideas and duty. 

Week 7 Post 2 Bush v. Gore


          In 2000, one of Americas most political events took place, a presidential election.[1] The election, between George W. Bush and Al Gore came down to one state, Florida. Florida was won by Bush, but by a margin of 1784 votes, less than one-half of 1%. By Florida law this required a manual recount, which shrunk the margin to 327 votes. Under state law a candidate may request a manual recount under these circumstances, which Gore did in 4 counties that were traditionally democratic leaning. However, time and politics caused the Florida Secretary of State Katherine Harris to declare Bush the winner of the election in Florida. Gores campaign than obtained an order from the Florida Supreme Court for a statewide manual recount. The next day the US Supreme Court ordered a stay of the recount. Many people filed various Amicus Curiae. Writing for a five-justice majority, Scalia argued that the votes that were ordered to be counted were not legally cast, and thus a recount could cause irreparable harm to Bush and the legitimacy of the democratic process. The dissenters however, felt that not ordering a recount would undermine the legitimacy of the democratic process and that the court should be careful taking actions that could determine the result of an election which lay outside of there power. However, 7 justices agreed that a manual statewide recount would violate the Equal Protection Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment, as standards for manual recounts varied across counties, such that individual voters could not be sure that their participation in the democratic process would be given proper weight. Many legal scholars and political figures felt that the Court had gone too far in addressing something outside its power under the political question doctrine, while others felt that it had not gone far enough in pointing out the need for nationwide electoral reform.

          The constitution is an oversight for politics and the supreme court interprets the constitution. Bush v. Gore is an example on how the Supreme Court is an oversight for politics, more specifically, when parts of the constitution conflict. Bush v. Gore is based on the precedence for presidential elections from the constitution, but also the fourteenth amendment. Thus, Bush v. Gore became a question on the reach of the authority of the court verses the duty it must interpret the constitution. In both instances, the court interacts with politics, whether they stayed to vote or not, the Court was involved in the outcome of the 2000 election. However, this forced interaction with politics is only against the principles of the supreme court if the ultimate decision comes out of personal biases. The end result is that the supreme court can interact with politics without being political, but the line can be easily crossed. 



[1] If I need to explain presidential elections, I’m leaving

Week 11 Post 3 TED Talk Reviews

     I am surprised that there is so little democracy in the election process. I am also intrigued by how long the American brand of constit...